Well I did see the Rockets play champ, and Scola was simply outstanding in the second half of the season, after the All-Star break, definately one of the top 5 rookies that's for sure!
But that still doesn't make him a star. Maybe with another season or two in the NBA, no doubt he's a very solid player and he can do some good things, great fundamentals and a good feel for the game, but I think calling 10 ppg and 5 rpg in the league a "legitimate star" is a bit much.
Anyway, I can see by your response that your a big Gaze supporter, and like I said before, I'm not hating on him. I love Australian Basketball and big ups to Gaze for being one of the best ever in this nation. My point was simply, that being great in the international level is extremely different from being great on the NBA level and it doesn't translate across.
example: That's why Brad Newley is one of Australia's top 3 players, and this Australian team was a legitimate top four contender after seeing them play strong against the US and Lithuania, but he can't even scrape it onto an NBA roster yet.
I'm not disagreeing with your opinion or taking shots at Gaze thoughh, everyone to their own.