Where will Judd land?

mattyj said:
I agree with you 100% Judd is being a complete and utter wanker about all this, and to be totally honest, what club wants to give a lot up for him, hes 24 years old and already showing signs of breaking down with his hip injury

I hope he never fully recovers, collingwood gives up heaps for him (Didak, Picks, etc) and both Collingwood and Judd end up screwed! :worthy:
Click to expand...

Yup, I was going to be fully supportive of his move as I understand the family thing (My work keeps me away from my family) but as every day passes it proves more & more the move home was just a pathetic reason to give the West Coast supporters to hang on. Yeah he wanted to move home but he couldn't just leave it at that and see who offers WCE the best deal (Giving ALL Victorian clubs a chance). Instead he has to DICTATE where he goes like he is some sort of gods gift to the AFL - &^$^% him !!!
 
Shoes said:
You sound very bitter :) ....GO PIES!!!
Click to expand...

Shoes - I am :mad:

Good for Collingwood - They have to give t a crack - I have no problem with them (Except it's the last team I wanted to see him go to). I have a problem with the way Judd has gone about this whole scenario and I think most people here would agree :eek:


I am SOOOOOO glad I sold my Judd Gold Signature card 1/2 way through this year (For a nice little profit) because I would be tempted to flog it for much less than it is worth just to get rid of it !!! I still have his silver signature which I will get rid of in the very near future !!! I have kept all other inserts & signature cards of previous WCE players as they are still part of my collection but the whole Judd scenario is leaving me a little bitter :mad:
 
No need to be bitter boys....its not like he is the only player in the league that has chased money before?

I am just as annoyed at anyone that he didnt join Melbourne....and would be equally pissed off if he joined Collingwood.

He is a gun and still one of the premier players in the league. No one seemed to dislike him when he was playing with West Coast....and like i said he isnt the only player that has ever chased money.
 
Benny J said:
No need to be bitter boys....its not like he is the only player in the league that has chased money before?

I am just as annoyed at anyone that he didnt join Melbourne....and would be equally pissed off if he joined Collingwood.

He is a gun and still one of the premier players in the league. No one seemed to dislike him when he was playing with West Coast....and like i said he isnt the only player that has ever chased money.
Click to expand...


If it was just the chasing of the money I might not be so bitter Benny but it is the lies he tells, the reasons he gives and the way he has gone about it. He has already admitted he decided to go home back at the end of 2005 yet he lied to the club (WCE) and asked them to leave him alone until the end of the season so he could concentrate on the season. He already knew what his D was and he played when he shouldn't have (told the coaching pannel he wanted to play) knowing it was his last season. I just hate the whole way this has gone down......
 
Besides.....if getting home to Melbourne was his main priority why wouldn't LOVE playing for the club he supported as a kid ?!?

Training Facilities not good enough - Bull &%$ing sh*t

Man I better get off this subject........before I get into trouble (lol)
 
Well i dont think therre was really any doubt he would likely head to Collingwood.

Eddie would always have the means to ensure he was attracted and inclined to head to the Pies.

As for the Eagles, well considering the fact they knowingly played him when he was well below 100% i hope they end up with a whole lot of nothing in return.
 
Why is everyone so against Judd going to Collingwood?? I mean i know its "cool" to hate Collingwood but if u support freo, hawks, cats, why is everyone so against judd collingwood?
 
basketoz74 said:
Well i dont think therre was really any doubt he would likely head to Collingwood.

Eddie would always have the means to ensure he was attracted and inclined to head to the Pies.

As for the Eagles, well considering the fact they knowingly played him when he was well below 100% i hope they end up with a whole lot of nothing in return.
Click to expand...

Mate they played him because he DEMANDED to play !!!
The last game he did the same again but he was that far gone the committe has to say no !

Don't blame the WCE on that one

As for him going to Collingwood....I knew that would be where he ended up so I put $$$ on him @ $3.00 on Sportingbet Australia !!!
 
ozguy3825 said:
Why is everyone so against Judd going to Collingwood?? I mean i know its "cool" to hate Collingwood but if u support freo, hawks, cats, why is everyone so against judd collingwood?
Click to expand...

1 - Because of the way Judd has gone about it
2 - Because we all hate Collingwood and it is the last team we want him to go to for that reason :)
3 - For WCE Supporters - Becuase of the way Collingwood got Mick Malhouse (when he was still under contract) and used the - I want to go home reason (again)
 
But honestly guys i'm a massive pies fan and i dont care who they are chasing i only care about what we have to give up to get them. The latest i've heard is Leon Davis, Goldsack, Ben Reid and our DP. Now call me stupid but Judd isnt going to get any better so why would u mess with your younger group to pull in a player who has reached their peak?? I honestly couldnt care less where he lands because no matter where he lands Judd and that team is going to have huge pressure on them to do really well next year. And either way u look at it WC wont get what they want for him. As i said hes not going to get any better and if this groin injury is here to stay i feel sorry for the team that gets him. On the other hand he could lift a team like carlton but then they will have to get rid of some of their young up and comers and the DP, lose lose really IMP.
 
Mate they played him because he DEMANDED to play !!!
Click to expand...

Personal Opinion, Rumour or Fact?

And as for the process i am not saying Judd has gone about it the right way....i wholeheartedly agree the system has been manipulated, as a Collingwood fan i could care less as long as Eddie & Co dont mrotgage the farm.

As for the Eagles well i personally have little concern for how they feel, what they get if anything, and what the reaction for Judd is to be. The Eagles will have to swallow big and about time, only thing that would finish it off for me would be for Cousins to skip town for a movie career or the like while on his next LA adventure....

Players, managers and various persons utilise systems in place everyday to make the most of the scenarios placed before them, and in Judd's case he has merely done this.


Good luck to him whereever he goes, even if we dont get him...
 
ozguy3825 said:
But honestly guys i'm a massive pies fan and i dont care who they are chasing i only care about what we have to give up to get them. The latest i've heard is Leon Davis, Goldsack, Ben Reid and our DP. Now call me stupid but Judd isnt going to get any better so why would u mess with your younger group to pull in a player who has reached their peak?? I honestly couldnt care less where he lands because no matter where he lands Judd and that team is going to have huge pressure on them to do really well next year. And either way u look at it WC wont get what they want for him. As i said hes not going to get any better and if this groin injury is here to stay i feel sorry for the team that gets him. On the other hand he could lift a team like carlton but then they will have to get rid of some of their young up and comers and the DP, lose lose really IMP.
Click to expand...

I'm dumbfounded...an objective Collingwood supporter! :razz:
 
ozguy3825 said:
So if Didak and Leon said they wanted to go home, you wouldnt want them over there?
Click to expand...

Of course we would but we are not having a go at the fact that he wants to go home, we are having go at him for trying to DICTATE where he goes !!!

He even refused to talk to Hawthorn.....what is with that?
Who does he think he is?

Let Richmond draft him for nothing I say........he couldn't do a thing about it, if you nominate for the draft you have to take what you get !!!

Unless your Chris Judd - Or so he thinks anyways....
 
I hope he gets stuck with Richmond or Carlton - because he already proved he wasn't being legitimate by not giving Hawthorn a shot - Actually I don't care if he goes to Collingwood either i am thankful he is not going to Hawthorn with that holier than thou attitude.... we are a TEAM... we play as a team - a look at me I'm God's gift to football player is not what we need so good on ya Judd :)
 
wolvesjr34 said:
I hope he gets stuck with Richmond or Carlton - because he already proved he wasn't being legitimate by not giving Hawthorn a shot - Actually I don't care if he goes to Collingwood either i am thankful he is not going to Hawthorn with that holier than thou attitude.... we are a TEAM... we play as a team - a look at me I'm God's gift to football player is not what we need so good on ya Judd :)
Click to expand...

Yeah well now I understand where you were coming from before AJ !
I agree with your thoughts on the matter !!!
 
If he's not going to come to Richmond, I hope he becomes the next Brownlow winner trade bust like Woewodin, Akermanis or Brian Wilson. Although I have a feeling he could be like a Greg Williams or Peter Moore and win another Brownlow....
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

CRUISER77
2024 27th Gippsland Vintage,Retro and Collectables Fair 2024
Replies
0
Views
230
CRUISER77
CRUISER77
W
NRL Card talk, anything I might not know etc.
Replies
19
Views
1,741
saintsforever
saintsforever
D
Latest PC additions
Replies
10
Views
1,073
Dodgydave
D
Back
Top Bottom