Nicest/Worst players to get signatures from

Best - Scott Sattler, David Mead, Matt Srama, Manu Vatuvei, Simon Mannering, Webcke, Aaron Woods... theres heaps

Worst - Tuqiri, Meninga, Prince (smudging) i havent had many bad experiences other than these
 
GiRDS- said:
i forgot to mention the stewart brothers and lyon in mine earlier, but i thought that it just went without saying that everyone knew that manly were the grubbiest people to deal with ever. actually i apologise, steve matai, matt ballin and kieran foran are some of the nicest blokes youll ever meet, but the rest of the side, we oh wow weeeeee.
Click to expand...

every team Manly plahy up here im busy, maybe its a good thing
 
your sub conscious is telling you not to bother with sigs that week, because it would be pointless anyway
 
The Mad Hatter said:
Getting a photo and a smile from Isaac Luke at the RLWC 2008 at the SFS was like pulling teeth through his anus.

Never wants to sign anything at fan days either (and other players rib him for it).

Probably the reason why he hasn't had a card in the past 3 releases (Elite '13, Traders and Powerplay '14)
Click to expand...


Sounds about right.
Not sure if he changed his signature or just couldn't be bothered but it went form "Bully" to 3 circles with a like through it. lol
 
I must say the whole time I have been getting sigs some players have good days and bad days, my worst ever Glenn Stewart absolute wanker, others Parker, meninga, tuquri, prince, Ashley Harrison, cronk, the best smith, vatuvei , buderus, sims , woods , Hargreaves , there's plenty more good ones
 
Don't bother getting sigs anymore, but back in the day when I did, the best were Steve Simpson, Robbie O'Davis and Darren Albert.

Worst was Ben Kennedy who wouldn't sign anything coz he was playing with a broken hand at the time. Understandable I guuueeeess ... :lol:
 
worst. Mark Gasnier Looks like Mr Squiggle Signs cards for him.

2397421488_ce665c8947.jpg
 
Last edited:
Agree with NRL FAN.

I once asked Mal Meninga to sign a few cards back in 1995 as a ball boy and he said to me "mate I'll sign 1 of those and that's it".

I then asked Laurie Daley to sign about 22 cards (he was my fav player) and he happily did so whilst having a chat to me..
 
My worst would have to be Darius Boyd. In 4 attempts he has never signed a single thing for me. Not a jersey or a single card. Just walks round on the phone for 15 minutes without saying a single word.
 
Maybe a few forumer's should refer to the Sig Pig fiasco thread to understand why certain players have an attitude when it comes to signing anything, think about their 'intellectual rights', it all comes down to the integrity of the person requesting the signature, do they get it because they are a fan or is because it's purely financial gain.
 
Daz said:
My worst would have to be Darius Boyd. In 4 attempts he has never signed a single thing for me. Not a jersey or a single card. Just walks round on the phone for 15 minutes without saying a single word.
Click to expand...

How does Josh Reynolds go for autos? Him and Boyd both seem like real douche bags
 
Best experiences, El Masri, Sailor, T.Sims, Gordon, Lockyer, Wiki, Mannering.
Worst, Lazarus, M.Minichelo, Cronk, R.Stuart.

Have heard the stories on Meninga & Tiquri. From one chance at Mal i was able to get 2 cards signed, full sigs n no drama. From one shot at Lote i also got a hassel free sig. I only assume becuse ive caught them both with little to no crowd chasin sigs at the time
 
ghosty said:
Best experiences, El Masri, Sailor, T.Sims, Gordon, Lockyer, Wiki, Mannering.
Worst, Lazarus, M.Minichelo, Cronk, R.Stuart.

Have heard the stories on Meninga & Tiquri. From one chance at Mal i was able to get 2 cards signed, full sigs n no drama. From one shot at Lote i also got a hassel free sig. I only assume becuse ive caught them both with little to no crowd chasin sigs at the time
Click to expand...

how did you have problems with Mini? what happened I've never seen anyone say that before
 
never got cards signed but i got a hat signed and a jersey and it was cool. No one seemed mean or rejected to sign it.
 
Also I dont get why people think Luke is mean, I got to go into the hall that leads to the sheds at halftime once and he winked at me.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

W
NRL Card talk, anything I might not know etc.
Replies
19
Views
1,602
saintsforever
saintsforever
skip20
Boomer, not a Boomer mailday....
Replies
8
Views
318
SharpysSports
SharpysSports
skip20
A rare double rainbow sighting...(okay, not so rare at all) lol
Replies
8
Views
404
Essellohbeebeewhy
Essellohbeebeewhy
skip20
How NOT to finish a set chase - Part 2
Replies
16
Views
1,195
skip20
skip20
skip20
A Mighty Small Mailday
Replies
7
Views
83
GarnettFan4Life
GarnettFan4Life
Back
Top Bottom