Who would you rather... Interesting little game

Pick one

  • Mystery Player A

    Votes: 8 38.1%

  • Mystery Player B

    Votes: 13 61.9%
  • Total voters
    21
Each to their own. I also wasn't saying ai doesn't have a bball iq, I think he was more an instinctive player. The really really great players like mj, Kobe, bird, magic had the iqs and don't play on pure instincts. They lead to titles.
 
spurlec said:
Each to their own. I also wasn't saying ai doesn't have a bball iq, I think he was more an instinctive player. The really really great players like mj, Kobe, bird, magic had the iqs and don't play on pure instincts. They lead to titles.
Click to expand...
Fair call.

Aleast if it ever comes down to a fantasy draft for the 1996 draft class, there wont be any arguments here haha
 
Matty4292 said:
Why though? This is my point. Ignore career achievements.

Take Shaq and Pau away from Kobe, would he have championships? Would Iverson have had a better career?
Click to expand...

I was ignoring career achievements! Would you wanna be on a team where the best player doesn't really care about practice to improve himself/the team and stays out late drinking/gambling or with a guy who is driven to be among the best players' to ever lace up a sneaker? You asked a simple question and I gave you the easy answer(sic).

Now, if the question was 'Who would you rather pay money to watch play'? Then it's AI, without a doubt.
 
the stats will change week to week if its current, but lets consider Kobe, Mello, Lebron, Harden, Durant... perhaps a few more possiblilites too

At the end of the day they are all strong players, so how do you pick one over the other ? With such similar stats you cant make a strong argument, it depends on who your team mates are... As michael jordan said their is no I in team, but there is an i and win.
 
NewtotheGame said:
the stats will change week to week if its current, but lets consider Kobe, Mello, Lebron, Harden, Durant... perhaps a few more possiblilites too

At the end of the day they are all strong players, so how do you pick one over the other ? With such similar stats you cant make a strong argument, it depends on who your team mates are... As michael jordan said their is no I in team, but there is an i and win.
Click to expand...

if its a question of starting a team around any star who is a current player the answer is easy for me and i would take tim duncan over anyone currently in the league, even at his age now and if it was while they were in their prime he was simply unstoppable on the post and probably the quitest leader ever
 
NewtotheGame said:
the stats will change week to week if its current, but lets consider Kobe, Mello, Lebron, Harden, Durant... perhaps a few more possiblilites too

At the end of the day they are all strong players, so how do you pick one over the other ? With such similar stats you cant make a strong argument, it depends on who your team mates are... As michael jordan said their is no I in team, but there is an i and win.
Click to expand...
Their career stats aren't even close.

Perhaps Melo and KD... Harden averages 14ppg for his career and LeBron is the one to average more than 5 assists per game

Harden
14.0ppg 2.7apg 3.5rpg

Kobe
25.5ppg 4.7apg 5.3rpg

Melo
24.8ppg 3.1apg 6.3rpg

KD
26.4ppg 2.9apg 6.7rpg

LeBron
27.6ppg 6.9apg 7.2rpg

Harden is way off the mark, Melo & KD are similar, LeBron has clearly the best stats.

And what I'm talking about has nothing to do with team mates. I'm talking individual players hence the reason I'm ignoring career achievements because you obviously need a good team to win. I'm talking purely how good individual players are.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom