Where will Judd land?

MetallicA' · Sep 23, 2007

Bruce reminds me off Judd alot in how he goes about his footy but obviously he is NO WHERE near as talented as the great man. Green will probally Captain next year to i think and Judd, Brock, Neita and Bruce will all be in the leadership group.
Ben maybe if Judd comes to Melbourne he will finally teach Bruce how to kick haha because theirs no doubting his durability as a footballer.

nenjabin · Sep 23, 2007

MetallicA' said:
Bruce reminds me off Judd alot in how he goes about his footy but obviously he is NO WHERE as near as talented as the great man. Green will probally Captain next year to i think and Judd, Brock, Neita and Bruce will all be in the leadership group.
Ben maybe if Judd comes to Melbourne he will finally teach Bruce how to kick haha because theirs no doubting his durability as a footballer.

Oh so now you're on the 'Green for Captain' idea? Hehe I'm pretty sure I said Green or Macca a month or so back I loved Green's leadership this year. He didn;t have a steller/stand out year, but the little things he did showing his maturity and leadership really impressed me. He was continually plugging holes, which of course there were many of this year, which is why he didn;t stand out. If Judd does come, would be a perfect switch over Green, to Judd to Jonesy as the Captain path
As for Bruce, hopefully Judd can teach him not only how to kick, but how to earn his whopping contract he's signed. It's 1 thing to average 24 touches a game as a Scott West style possession, but 24 touches a game with 50% of them backline nothings, and 50% of the remaining 12 being clangers is not earning squat. This year I was seriously ashamed that I had his number on my back...

MetallicA' · Sep 23, 2007

Yeh i kinda switched from McLean to Green because if Judd comes we will need someone with a bit of years and games played to their name to help lead the team. Im not saying McLean can't but he has only played 50 something games and as you saw with Kade Simpson at Carlton, it's a little to early to elevate someone to such an important role.
Green - Judd - McLean - Jones (That's a nice looking Captaincy Capsule i must say )

Richo · Sep 23, 2007

I would be VERY happy with Melbourne's 1st pick & TJ for Judd, what do you say Metal shall we sign the dotted line ?

nenjabin · Sep 23, 2007

Richo said:
I would be VERY happy with Melbourne's 1st pick & TJ for Judd, what do you say Metal shall we sign the dotted line ?

As an official spokesmen for Metallica, I shall step in and do the signing on his behalf Deal!!

MetallicA' · Sep 23, 2007

hahaha. Signed, Sealed and Delivered with a bag of Pot

side note: how do you resize an image so its less than 24kb? I want to update my avatar

Shihad · Sep 23, 2007

Geez the Judd and Melbourne talk seems to have gotten the Melbourne supporters a bit excited I will still stick by my statement and say Judd's best years will be behind him. I can see the $$$ being a liability to whoever picks him up. Juddy has fantastic footy smarts though, so he'll always been a great player, just not at the 110% peak of what we've seen in the past. That and his contract is a massive risk IMO.

I hope he proves me wrong, as I feel he'd slot in fantastically at Melbourne. Getting rid of Johnstone would work in your favour too I feel. I'd also get rid of Miller like you guys have said.

MetallicA' · Sep 27, 2007

Well reported on SEN that Judd is coming to the Demons. It was meant to b announced on the footy show tonight and than people who work for the network couldnt keep a lid on it and everyone jumped on the strong rumour. So keep your eyes peeled to the footy show tonight!!

YOU BEAUTY!! If this is 100% true it is just about the biggest and boldest move in our clubs history!

Ja$e · Sep 27, 2007

MetallicA' said:
Well reported on SEN that Judd is coming to the Demons. It was meant to b announced on the footy show tonight and than people who work for the network couldnt keep a lid on it and everyone jumped on the strong rumour. So keep your eyes peeled to the footy show tonight!!

YOU BEAUTY!! If this is 100% true it is just about the biggest and boldest move in our clubs history!

Good or bad though, only time will tell!

MetallicA' · Sep 27, 2007

Good. Even if he did go down injured again *touch wood*, just think about what it does to our club financially having Judd at the MFC! Our club was a joke in comparrison to just about every club in the AFL, we got slammed by all the journo's and when a big story came along at demonland it was always overshadowed by a smaller story from a bigger profile club. Memberships will go up and the Dee's will have the best player in the AFL on its playing list. Its kinda like a fairytale as Judd supported the Dee's as a kid and he now will be playing for them. Apparently Judd was gobsmacked at how brilliant Bailey's presentation was and Bails was a big factor in us getting the champion.

Bailey
Conolley
Judd

We've started the off season in flying colours. When this gets announced it will be interesting to see the deal in writing with what both clubs will get.

AndrewG23 · Sep 27, 2007

hmmm, im dissapointed if this is true but on the other hand, im happy with the club hes going to. i couldnt stand him going to the pies, lol.

Richo · Sep 27, 2007

MetallicA' said:
Well reported on SEN that Judd is coming to the Demons. It was meant to b announced on the footy show tonight and than people who work for the network couldnt keep a lid on it and everyone jumped on the strong rumour. So keep your eyes peeled to the footy show tonight!!

YOU BEAUTY!! If this is 100% true it is just about the biggest and boldest move in our clubs history!

I hope your right mate, I don't mind seeing him going to the team he supported as a kid
Do you know what Melbourne is going to give up for him ???

nenjabin · Sep 27, 2007

MetallicA' said:
Well reported on SEN that Judd is coming to the Demons. It was meant to b announced on the footy show tonight and than people who work for the network couldnt keep a lid on it and everyone jumped on the strong rumour. So keep your eyes peeled to the footy show tonight!!

YOU BEAUTY!! If this is 100% true it is just about the biggest and boldest move in our clubs history!

OMG OMG OMG OMG! Hell yeah! This better not be false! haha

Billyhoyle · Sep 27, 2007

has it been announced footy show started at 8:30

ScottE · Sep 27, 2007

If it is true get on him with sportsbet as he is paying $3 still with Melb.

MetallicA' · Sep 28, 2007

maybe it will wait until after the GF this Saturday. Think the sports bet on TAB has been stripped of the Judd Bet and it was just after this rumour was announced.

It was all over the internet late afternoon yesterday and ABC radio were confirming it but SEN are starting to deny its authenticy. All a smokescreen i think, i am preety confident in Judd being in the red and the blue and hopefully it comes out officially today or at the latest Monday.

nenjabin · Sep 28, 2007

MetallicA' said:
maybe it will wait until after the GF this Saturday. Think the sports bet on TAB has been stripped of the Judd Bet and it was just after this rumour was announced.

It was all over the internet late afternoon yesterday and ABC radio were confirming it but SEN are starting to deny its authenticy. All a smokescreen i think, i am preety confident in Judd being in the red and the blue and hopefully it comes out officially today or at the latest Monday.

And I was so tempted to take those odds of $7 a week or so ago...haha

Benny J · Sep 28, 2007

Oh...please be true!!

NBAWHIZ · Sep 28, 2007

As a Magpies fan i hope the Judd-Melbourne rumours aren't true, but i have a gut feeling that Judd will go to Melbourne. The rumour is that it will be a three-way trade between Melbourne, West Coast, and St Kilda. The trade will go something like this;

St Kilda gets James Frawley from Melbourne

Melbourne gets Chris Judd from West Coast

West Coast gets Melbourne's First Draft Pick
West Coast gets St Kilda's First Draft Pick
West Coast gets a Melbourne Player of their choice (maybe Miller)

It's only a rumour at this stage, but it does sound like it would be a good deal for all 3 Teams involved.

ScottE · Sep 29, 2007

See Judd to melb has come into $1.70

I put 100 on him thurs night when the rumors started and i got him at $3.

Go Melb lol

Where will Judd land?

Ricky Davis Collector

World's #1 Pat Burke Collector

Ricky Davis Collector

OzCardTrader

World's #1 Pat Burke Collector

Ricky Davis Collector

OzCardTrader

Ricky Davis Collector

To infinity and beyond...

Ricky Davis Collector

OzCardTrader

OzCardTrader

World's #1 Pat Burke Collector

Im Not Juan Garcia

Go Brock

Ricky Davis Collector

World's #1 Pat Burke Collector

Mr Big Shot...

Good Old Collingwood

Go Brock

Similar threads

Privacy & Transparency

Privacy & Transparency