NRL Collectors - Question 1 - Cut Signatures

Matt26 · Dec 17, 2011

Hi everyone,

I have a little project on the go at the moment and need some feedback from our wonderful NRL collectors here:

Would you be interested in cut signature cards being part of an NRL release?

Say for example, for NRL Series 1 2012, if there were 10 cut signature cards inserted as a redemption card, all numbered 1/1.

Example checklist below:

1 - Wayne Bennett
2 - Phil Gould
3 - Andrew Johns
4 - Brad Fittler
5 - Wally Lewis
6 - Mal Meninga
7 - Terry Lamb
8 - Laurie Daley
9 - Cliff Lyons
10 - Peter Sterling

Would this be a selling point for you? Would this make you want to buy more packs/boxes knowing these cards were in there? The players may change but you get my drift.

For those that dont know what a cut signature card is, here is one below:

Love to hear your thoughts on this? Would it work?

Cheers
Matt

1967Sharks · Dec 17, 2011

If they were in champions then HELL YES!
I am not a fan of cut signatures though as there is no link between the player and your actual card (Just like sticker autos)
If its just another added insert and doesnt take away anything, you would have to be crazy to say no.

Matt26 · Dec 17, 2011

Thanks for the feedback.

Im guessing if there was a Steve Rogers card you would be interested? LOL

Some of these cards could also be cut signatures of players/coaches that are sadly no longer alive. Steve Rogers/Jack Gibson/Peter Jackson/Arthur Beetson/Ben Alexander etc. Baseball has a lot of these cut signature cards of players that are no longer with us and it wouldnt necessarily be current players more your legends etc.

Cheers
Matt

Rekless · Dec 17, 2011

If it was legends then yes. If it was current players or even players retired in the last 15 years then id be less keen.

AyiosYiorgos · Dec 17, 2011

the answer would be yes from everyone

ooneil · Dec 17, 2011

Anything that shows any sort of innovation what so ever in the NRL card area will be a hit.

AyiosYiorgos · Dec 17, 2011

well someone voted no

AyiosYiorgos said:
the answer would be yes from everyone

Noark-99 · Dec 17, 2011

I'm not a fan of 1/1 cards..... Simply because you have no chance of completing a set.. 1/10 maybe.. But.. Truth is I wouldn't complain if it actually happened......

So I am the second "No" on that one....

mischap123 · Dec 17, 2011

Are these say literally cut out of an old cheque or something?

Noark-99 · Dec 17, 2011

mischap123 said:
Are these say literally cut out of an old cheque or something?

That would be interesting to see....

Bulldogss · Dec 17, 2011

mischap123 said:
Are these say literally cut out of an old cheque or something?

That's what it is,they cut the signature of someone famous and stick the sig on his picture,I'd say yes to it only if the person was dead.
Cheers
Peter

AyiosYiorgos · Dec 17, 2011

everyone will die eventually.....

Bulldogss said:
That's what it is,they cut the signature of someone famous and stick the sig on his picture,I'd say yes to it only if the person was dead.
Cheers
Peter

king megator · Dec 17, 2011

I am not a fan of this unless that player has been out of the game for just say 30-40 years.... I really think that it looks cheap and to have someones old electricity bill on a so called Signature card looks like crap???? Come on get for real here....

thenamesgould · Dec 17, 2011

What is the point of having cut signatures of those players and coaches listed in the first post, when they could just get them to sign some cards properly?!

1/1 isn't something I want either, it would ruin my Newcastle Knights collection!

king megator · Dec 17, 2011

Like what i said , these i honestly think that they look very cheap.... Where would you display them , in your toilet.... Anyway everyone to there own i guess....

ch0pzta · Dec 17, 2011

So a cut signature is a physical sample taken from an unrelated item the player has signed at some point in their life?

If so, then yeah why not, especially if the player has passed away and a new signature is impossible.

Brplat · Dec 17, 2011

Guys, its better than what we get now im all for it!

Carter · Dec 17, 2011

I voted No because it seems so plastic and just for the sake of it!

We are not the USA and i find the more we follow their card system the less people become interested because it is near impossible to complete an entire year without paying thousands of dollars and nowadays due to so many subsets and signatures unless you buy several cases and pick the eyes out of it you get lost and disinterested!
By saying that my personal preference has always been the older cards because they were simple and collectable, now all the collecting is in the hands of dealers not individuals!

GU = GAME WORN, anything else is haphazard and just for the sake of following the US!
Just my opinion!

steven1959 · Dec 17, 2011

Sixth no. same as event worn...where is the reality..but know quite well this will follow the NBA and NFL line. The cheaper solution to game worn. If a game worn can be bought for less than say tops 1000$ and divided into 150 sigs and 300 non sigs, what would be the rise in production cost per 5,000 boxes. Give us a break Select, your just greedy or plain lazy. Someone else will do top level and bang we will have EXQUISITE standard. Yesssss

Matt26 · Dec 17, 2011

steven1959 said:
Sixth no. same as event worn...where is the reality..but know quite well this will follow the NBA and NFL line. The cheaper solution to game worn. If a game worn can be bought for less than say tops 1000$ and divided into 150 sigs and 300 non sigs, what would be the rise in production cost per 5,000 boxes. Give us a break Select, your just greedy or plain lazy. Someone else will do top level and bang we will have EXQUISITE standard. Yesssss

Im not sure what Select have to do with this. Its merely a question I hve put up and used one of their cards as a demo.

Regards
Matt

NRL Collectors - Question 1 - Cut Signatures

Would you like to see cut signatures included in an NRL release?

Yes

No

OzCardTrader

OzCardTrader

Card Addict

OzCardTrader

Card Addict

One Day! Cowboys!

OzCardTrader

One Day! Cowboys!

Dogs of war

Card Addict

OzCardTrader

OzCardTrader

OzCardTrader

OzCardTrader

Penrith Panthers 2021/2022/2023/2024 Premiers

OzCardTrader

OzCardTrader

Similar threads

Privacy & Transparency

Privacy & Transparency