Where will Judd land?

wolvesjr34 · Sep 17, 2007

nenjabin said:
I stand by this. And as a non-biased Melbourne supporter. What could any other club offer him except more money?

Hawthorn will be offering him and his family a future outside football - Hwks have always been big adn have focused more on helping their player sbeyond football. ANd Judd still wants to win and I dunno if that can happen at Melbourne straight away... but they are a strange side in the way they bounce from bad to good season to season.

I can dream of Hawthorn bound but the only vertical stripes Judd will be wearing will be black and white ones.

Perhaps Campbell Brown can tell Judd that he owes him one LMAO

Or if you wanna be a conspiracy theorist.... the Brown incident... some comments Crawf has made in the media... its coy like he knows something is going to happen... a bit like he was with regards to Croady coming back to the Hawks....

but hey I know I am being unrealistic... but its about time something went truly right for Hawthorn...

steve-o · Sep 17, 2007

would westcoast accept this
picks 3,20,36 and josh kenndey a wa boy

for

judd

AndrewG23 · Sep 17, 2007

steve-o said:
would westcoast accept this
picks 3,20,36 and josh kenndey a wa boy

for

judd

i reckon they would steve, plus judd can get all the money he wants because we have Pratt, LoL!

nenjabin · Sep 17, 2007

AndrewG23 said:
blues are on the rise. maybe not the upcoming season, but in 2 or 3 seasons we can be a team like hawthorn or collingwood are now.

we've been on the bottom too long to stay there any longer. if we dont get him then its gotta be collingwood for sure because i cant see melbourne or bombers getting him.....

Dude, you have NO backline! You're on the rise, yes, in the midfield. But you need a defence to go anywhere. This is exactly why Collingwood and Hawthorn are where they are. You also have no young key position players coming through, and only old ones moving on and going crazy in the head...

wolvesjr34 · Sep 17, 2007

nenjabin said:
Dude, you have NO backline! You're on the rise, yes, in the midfield. But you need a defence to go anywhere. This is exactly why Collingwood and Hawthorn are where they are. You also have no young key position players coming through, and only old ones moving on and going crazy in the head...

LMAO I was about to go off at you but realised you weren't talking about Hawthorn cos I was gonna throw names like Buddy franklin at ya LMAO

steve-o · Sep 17, 2007

nenjabin you are right about our backline andrewg23 i love the blues and we need judd for midfield pace

prat your right he is a sugar daddy he is worth 4.7 billion beacuse of visy company and has a 20 percent share in bhp so he knows what he is doing

its been mentioned the blues are willing to give judd $1.5 million a year for 5 years
but westcoast are playing hardball so they should judd is a champion player.

AndrewG23 · Sep 17, 2007

yeah, ill give you that, our backline is poor. Our midfield has been strong for a while though.

who are all our old players that are going crazy in the head?

wolvesjr34 · Sep 17, 2007

steve-o said:
nenjabin you are right about our backline andrewg23 i love the blues and we need judd for midfield pace

prat your right sugar daddy

its been mentioned the blues are willing to give judd $1.5 million a year for 5 years
but westcoast are playing hardball so the should judd is a champion player.

great way to cripple your ability to resign budding stars... that's why I think Hawthorn might be a chance cos Judd is smart... he won't choose the most money - he'll choose the best circumstances! Which is probably collingwood. But damn I keep saying this - I can dream!

AndrewG23 · Sep 17, 2007

wolvesjr34 said:
great way to cripple your ability to resign budding stars... that's why I think Hawthorn might be a chance cos Judd is smart... he won't choose the most money - he'll choose the best circumstances! Which is probably collingwood. But damn I keep saying this - I can dream!

AJ, Juddy said he has chosen 4 teams, Carlton, Collingwood, Essendon, Melbourne.

fastbaja5b · Sep 17, 2007

*Eagles move to Lilydale... resign Judd*

wolvesjr34 · Sep 17, 2007

AndrewG23 said:
AJ, Juddy said he has chosen 4 teams, Carlton, Collingwood, Essendon, Melbourne.

Right BEFORE meeting with club representatives - footy classifieds is a rumour mill we'll see.

I'm not doubting you - but I consider that ill considered and I don't see Judd as an ill considered person.

Besides its already been rumoured that Judd favours Collingwood and Hawthorn for opportunities to win... that rumour at least comes from someone close to Judd... I don't imagine Judd would have even created a short list yet... but if you're right you're right... I still think Collingwood. Carlton have nothing but cash to offer. And to say Carlton would be above Hawthorn in choice of destination is frankly, absurd.... (and would only be out of feeling some sense of debt to the Eagles not because he'd WANT to play there).

nenjabin · Sep 17, 2007

AndrewG23 said:
yeah, ill give you that, our backline is poor. Our midfield has been strong for a while though.

who are all our old players that are going crazy in the head?

Old players: Whitnall, Kouta gone

Crazy: Fev

Ja$e · Sep 17, 2007

Anyway it goes we don't want any Vics in the trade to Judd because they will sign for a year and then go in the draft ****ing us over period!

AndrewG23 · Sep 17, 2007

nenjabin said:
Old players: Whitnall, Kouta gone

Crazy: Fev

Whitnall is 28,not that old IMO and as you said, Kouta is gone.

Maybe we can trade Fev for a good backman???:-k

wolvesjr34 · Sep 17, 2007

Ja$e said:
Anyway it goes we don't want any Vics in the trade to Judd because they will sign for a year and then go in the draft ****ing us over period!

So awthorn can offer Mark Williams a WA native and perhaps Chance bateman... that's not a bad offer at all considering he shouldnt' realistically want to go to Carlton... lol

nenjabin · Sep 17, 2007

AndrewG23 said:
Whitnall is 28,not that old IMO and as you said, Kouta is gone.

Maybe we can trade Fev for a good backman???:-k

Whitnall is 28, but is done and dusted.

wolvesjr34 · Sep 17, 2007

AndrewG23 said:
Whitnall is 28,not that old IMO and as you said, Kouta is gone.

Maybe we can trade Fev for a good backman???:-k

Whitnall has fitness issues - great football brain but fitness issues... I don't think he loves the game enough.

AndrewG23 · Sep 17, 2007

nenjabin said:
Whitnall is 28, but is done and dusted.

ok, maybe we can trade Fev and Whitnall for a good backman, :lol:

wolvesjr34 · Sep 17, 2007

AndrewG23 said:
ok, maybe we can trade Fev and Whitnall for a good backman,

I'm sure the Bulldogs or Richmond are up for a ridiculous trade :lol:

nenjabin · Sep 17, 2007

AndrewG23 said:
ok, maybe we can trade Fev and Whitnall for a good backman,

Fev is crazy, but you need him, and I'd take him at Melbourne anyday! Plus there is word Rattan said he wouldn;t take the job if Fev wasn't there

Whitnall, no 1 will want. If Carlton doesn;t re-sign him, he's finished.

Where will Judd land?

Morrow Super Collector

Banned User

OzCardTrader

World's #1 Pat Burke Collector

Morrow Super Collector

Banned User

OzCardTrader

Morrow Super Collector

OzCardTrader

Banned User

Morrow Super Collector

World's #1 Pat Burke Collector

To infinity and beyond...

OzCardTrader

Morrow Super Collector

World's #1 Pat Burke Collector

Morrow Super Collector

OzCardTrader

Morrow Super Collector

World's #1 Pat Burke Collector

Similar threads