well if you want to get technical, he didnt actually ask how paninis redemption system worked, he just asked how redemptions in general work, hes just seen loads of "panini" redemptions (surprise, surprise). I didnt actually name any company as its not really relevant to the question but no, it wasnt upper deck. Congratulations on recieveing your redemptions so fast, you must be happy you had to go through that process instead of the cards being in the box's. And as for my way of words, it was quiet simple really, just a " Hi, can i please request a replacement, thankyou" i suppose that could be taken the wrong way.
Ummm Brent, the initial question specifically says "especially from Panini", so if your going to get technical then you better read the details again, but it did still have a slightly general nature to the question, so I will give you the technicality, its just that when I read your post, all I thought of was my experiences with Upper Deck redemptions, so I just jumped to the conclusion that you were talking about Upper Deck. After all, out of all the redemptions I had with Upper Deck, admittedly not a huge sample number, but half were replaced with a non-redeemed card, without offer to wait first. And then when I pulled my first Panini redemption I automatically feared the worst. But low and behold, 3 years later and I am yet to fail to receive a single card that I redeemed (touch wood, hope I havent jinxed myself now lol), and the longest I have had to wait was 9 months.
Now redemptions are obviously not ideal, and I dont like them any more than the next guy, of course I would like to get every auto in hand, but I know that isnt going to happen, but mainly I dont like guys who reply to a question with a most negative response as if this was the way it was for everyone. If that is your experience, fair enough, but I cant help but think sometimes that, just as it is in normal everyday life, the negatives are always exaggerated, while positives, or at the very least, when expectations are met, they are downplayed or ignored completely.
Come on guys let's not angry over the situation
Cheers Josh, clearly one person is more angry/bitter than the other, but anyways, did you have any redemptions yourself, or was it purely a generic question?