You tell me the bowling attack they've had in the ODIs and T20s vs India and NZ has been much chop.
All this 'resting'.
There are 2, possibly 3, key performance indicators.
Batsmen score runs.
Bowlers take wickets.
Fielding.
Some players don't even qualify.
They let Johnson walk out because he was well and truly toast after constant touring, criticism etc. They ran Starc in to the ground. They took Hazelwood and stuffed him up. They changed Pattinson's action and it did him no good, so he changed back and took wickets. They keep telling us Cummins will play one day instead of telling him to go find a real job.
Surely Haddin would still be a better keeper than Scissorhands. Hell, Nevill, Paine and Hartley are in front of Wade IMHO as Wade just can't catch. It's deplorable.
The fielding has been sub standard. S Marsh misses regulation sitters and then looks like he's puffed a cone with that goofy smile.
They promote players like Maxwell who plays a good game here and there but PUT THE DINKY s*** AWAY SON!!!
Smith is only a run of outs away from people questioning not only his batting but his captaincy.
M Marsh is out of his depth too.
Then you've got guys in form not being picked at all.
Surely the selectors can see this?
Well written.
The worst thing of Johnson & to an extent Harris was the roads they were forced to bowl on in the 18 months leading up to their respective retirements. Harris was always injury prone but I really thing that these 'roads'sped up his retirement.
The loss of Coulter-Nile has hurt us also but credit where credit is due I think Hastings has been good for us, really hits the deck hard and has probably asked the most questions. I am not a big Richardson fan, really seems to have dropped pace in the last 12 months, I seem to recall him being mid 140's a while back.
The way in which Haddin was forced out of the national team was a joke. Neville is a good replacement and even though Haddin claims to be happy with how he finished I thought he deserved better. Wade is terrible, Hartley and Paine are twice the keepers he is. If they wanted a part time keeper for the T20 why not Ben Dunk. He left QLD as he was behind Hartley and can really bat.
S.Marsh and M.Marsh, the former reminds me a bit of the Marcus North situation and how they kept giving him a go until he would make a score (didn't matter how weak the opposition was) so he could justify another go. M.Marsh is a work in progress, struggling at present but not ready to scrap heap him yet. They love looking after the WA boys!
Ah the big show, put your damn head down! In saying that I would have him in the team almost solely for his fielding, a bit like Symonds until he hit that purple patch. He is worth a wicket and at least 20 runs with the ones that he stops and the pressure he creates and if he can just use his brain when he bats.
My ODI team based on form and selection availability;
Warner
Khawaja
Smith
Lynn / Burns
Bailey (just hanging on)
Maxwell
M.Marsh
Paine
Hastings
Hazlewood
Pattinson (not sure if he is injured at present)