Should Anthony Rocca be suspended?

[wolvesjr34]

I hope you choke on a peanut

Do you hope I choke and cough it up, or do you hope I choke and die?

 

[Richo]

He hasnt got a week yet! His appeal is happening now.

Actually he DOES have a week, the initial suspension was a week which I agree with

Matty - Good to see we do agree (Re no contact with the head) I was wondering if anyone did agree with what I said

 

[wolvesjr34]

Actually he DOES have a week, the initial suspension was a week which I agree with

Matty - Good to see we do agree (Re no contact with the head) I was wondering if anyone did agree with what I said

He doesn't get a week if he wins his appeal.

 

[Richo]

He doesn't get a week if he wins his appeal.

Your kidding........is that how it works ?

 

[wolvesjr34]

Your kidding........is that how it works ?

Bugger off with your sarcasm

 

[wall4ace]

Bugger off with your sarcasm

he a west coast supporter what did ya expect aj


cheers

 

[Richo]

Bugger off with your sarcasm

Hehe sorry mate, just pointing out what you said that was pretty obvious.
the point I was making before was that Rocca got 1 week from the initial tribunal and that I agreed with it......what-ever happens from here doesn't matter to me as I agreed with the initial assesment hence I think they did their job

 

[wolvesjr34]

Hehe sorry mate, just pointing out what you said that was pretty obvious.
the point I was making before was that Rocca got 1 week from the initial tribunal and that I agreed with it......what-ever happens from here doesn't matter to me as I agreed with the initial assesment hence I think they did their job

I see. I understand now.

 

[Magicman]

Rocca did not win his case he will now miss the next 2 games against the Hawks and Saints.....

 

[Richo]

Rocca did not win his case he will now miss the next 2 games against the Hawks and Saints.....

Well I did initially say 1 to 2 weeks........I didn't mean it literally though

 

[Magicman]

ahh well what can ya do? 2 weeks for a hip and shoulder and nothing for eye gouging....

MOVE ON!!!

 

[mattyj]

Good, much deserved suspension...

 

[Shihad]

I voted yes, not that I agree with the AFL's rules but at the start of the year the AFL clearly stated that they will not tolerate head-high contact. Anthony clearly made head high contact, end of story.

 

[ScottE]

What about earlier in the year when Luke Ball was knocked out and the player who did that didn't get sighted. Ball misses 2 games from that. Where's the consistency.

 

[nenjabin]

What about earlier in the year when Luke Ball was knocked out and the player who did that didn't get sighted. Ball misses 2 games from that. Where's the consistency.

Ball and Whelen banged heads accidently. Can;t compare

 

[Richo]

What about earlier in the year when Luke Ball was knocked out and the player who did that didn't get sighted. Ball misses 2 games from that. Where's the consistency.

Well that is a whole other discussion......this discussion was about Rocca getting suspended - And the majority voted - "He Should" and he did

 

[ScottE]

Ball and Whelen banged heads accidently. Can;t compare

It was still a shepard off the ball with high contact. That's all the rule states.

 

[nenjabin]

It was still a shepard off the ball with high contact. That's all the rule states.

True...but it was body on body and their heads in the whiplash clashed. Whelan was also out for that game and Ball was only out for the next 2 cause St. Kilda were being weird about it

 

[wolvesjr34]

What about earlier in the year when Luke Ball was knocked out and the player who did that didn't get sighted. Ball misses 2 games from that. Where's the consistency.

mate what country you live in? the tribunal has never been consistent!!

 

[white_chocolate_55]

well your no doubt going to win your next 2 now. (Yes win)