Reynolds might be the grimiest person on field but off field he is one of the nicest players you will meet. He will be a nice signing for the dogs.
As for city vs country issue, it's a disgrace that the dogs are allowed to withdraw when other teams couldn't, I guess it helps that Greenberg is the CEO of nrl.
As for the Roos team would definitely agree on the players you have listed but I would also include Thaiday at the top of that list, he is well passed his prime and is taking a spot that a player more deserving should have.