Interesting topic... Michael, Magic or Bird? Who do you take??

loafic · May 16, 2012

Watch this and then make comment on who you would take...

kingjack · May 16, 2012

I'd take Bird - white guy represent! Nah in all seriousness you can't go past Jordan. He is known as the for a reason.

Matt26 · May 16, 2012

very tough question, but I'd have to go for Magic. The ultimate playmaker....tough to go past Jordan and I love Bird but I'd still say Magic.

Harsha_12 · May 16, 2012

I'd Go Lebron....Hands Down...........jokes

In all seriousness MJ for me

ozguy3825 · May 16, 2012

For me Bird doesnt get a look in for me, great player but not as good as the other 2 imo. As 1 single player i'd take MJ but to add to a team probably Magic with Bird sitting rockin his mo with Morrison

Matty4292 · May 16, 2012

Magic, no doubt.

Magic's play making abilities could make J.R. Smith look like MJ

ozballer23 · May 17, 2012

Can't top the GOAT for me!

drobfan8 · May 20, 2012

People forget that Magic turned around L.A in his first year. He won a championship and the finals MVP AS A ROOKIE!!!

Amazing. I love Bird but it's a toss up between Magic and Jordan. Magic certainly would improve ANY team immediately, whereas Jordan took a while to make his team better.

lukesicari · May 21, 2012

Man it's tough. At the end of the day I'd have to go with MJ but not because of the scoring, because all 3 can do that. It's what Steve Kerr sad during the video, Jordan's DEFENSE was amazing. Much better defender then the other 2 and defense wins titles so I'd have to go with MJ. Great topic though, would love to see some more discussion in this thread!

Mully · May 21, 2012

Easily Jordan! You dont win scoring titles, rings, all defensives, MVP's for no reason!

loafic · May 25, 2012

LeBron/Durant/Kobe/Dwight 1st quartet to make All-NBA 3 straight years since Barkley/Jordan/Magic/Malone ('88-89 - '90-91).

Which raises the question...who ya got? LeBron/Durant/Kobe/Dwight or Barkley/Jordan/Magic/Malone?

drob50 · May 25, 2012

I take LeBron/Durant/Kobe/Dwight only because they have a C!

BoondasH1 · May 25, 2012

ozballer23 said:
Can't top the GOAT for me!

The Goat: http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0117450/

MJ became a team player and made others around him better players, add his competitive side and he would be my choice

Verse1 · May 25, 2012

loafic said:
LeBron/Durant/Kobe/Dwight 1st quartet to make All-NBA 3 straight years since Barkley/Jordan/Magic/Malone ('88-89 - '90-91).

Which raises the question...who ya got? LeBron/Durant/Kobe/Dwight or Barkley/Jordan/Magic/Malone?

Tough one. Could Barkley/Jordan/Magic/Malone hold Lebron/Durant/Kobe/Dwight to less points? Not too sure about that.
Im on the fence on this one

drob50 · May 25, 2012

Verse1 said:
Tough one. Could Barkley/Jordan/Magic/Malone hold Lebron/Durant/Kobe/Dwight to less points? Not too sure about that.
Im on the fence on this one

Got a new avatar for you

tagged · May 25, 2012

There's a catch to your pick, after a great career he decides to buy the club and manage it.
Mmmmmmmmm, I'll have Larry thanks guys.
Could take the Bobcats 5 years to get as many wins as Larry got this year in Indy.
With any of them your getting a legend.

tagged · May 25, 2012

Verse1 said:
Tough one. Could Barkley/Jordan/Magic/Malone hold Lebron/Durant/Kobe/Dwight to less points? Not too sure about that.
Im on the fence on this one

Rules have changed, are we playing by 1989 rules or 2012 rules?
Those four old guys would be on the bench teched out by 1/4 time in todays game.
Really your looking at eight guys that can't be stopped, and at least six that can really pass well.

FabFiveFan · May 25, 2012

tagged said:
There's a catch to your pick, after a great career he decides to buy the club and manage it.
Mmmmmmmmm, I'll have Larry thanks guys.
Could take the Bobcats 5 years to get as many wins as Larry got this year in Indy.
With any of them your getting a legend.

Haha, I like the catch. It certainly makes the decision a bit more difficult. Without any catches included Jordan wins over Magic. Obviously all 3 were awesome, arguably the best all time at their various positions, but there aint none better than The G.O.A.T.

Verse1 said:
Tough one. Could Barkley/Jordan/Magic/Malone hold Lebron/Durant/Kobe/Dwight to less points? Not too sure about that.
Im on the fence on this one

Tough tough call. Who would guard who, as there are a couple of positional differences for starters, but would love to see Charles and Lebron banging down in the post 90's style. Then again I could say the same thing about Malone and Dwight. I give smallest edge to old-timers, just coz they would have a chip on their shoulder about being challenged by the "young pups". Besides, Jordan would not let them lose to a team involving Kobe.

ozguy3825 · May 25, 2012

loafic said:
LeBron/Durant/Kobe/Dwight 1st quartet to make All-NBA 3 straight years since Barkley/Jordan/Magic/Malone ('88-89 - '90-91).

Which raises the question...who ya got? LeBron/Durant/Kobe/Dwight or Barkley/Jordan/Magic/Malone?

Tough 1, i really think MJ is above all but i think i'd have to take the new breed only because i really didnt see enough of Magic and Malone. Malone and Barkley were good player without being great for me. Certainly deserve to get their props but i think from a straight scoring point Lebron and co have it. Defence is a little closer but i still think with Bron, Dwight and Kobes D is tough to go past.

loafic · May 25, 2012

lovin this discussion... btw, saw it on twitter today

Interesting topic... Michael, Magic or Bird? Who do you take??

loafic

Walt Frazier Collector

kingjack

Dane Swan super collector.

Matt26

Harsha_12

#Believeland #Kyrie

ozguy3825

kobemania

Matty4292

Denver Nuggets Fan

ozballer23

#1 J.R. Smith Collector

drobfan8

OzCardTrader

lukesicari

formerly DW8

Mully

Hall Of Fame

loafic

Walt Frazier Collector

drob50

Magic Johnson and David Robinson ON CARD autos

BoondasH1

OzCardTrader

Verse1

No Glove, No love.

drob50

Magic Johnson and David Robinson ON CARD autos

tagged

OzCardTrader

tagged

OzCardTrader

FabFiveFan

OzCardTrader

ozguy3825

kobemania

loafic

Walt Frazier Collector

Interesting topic... Michael, Magic or Bird? Who do you take??

Walt Frazier Collector

Dane Swan super collector.

#Believeland #Kyrie

kobemania

Denver Nuggets Fan

#1 J.R. Smith Collector

OzCardTrader

formerly DW8

Hall Of Fame

Walt Frazier Collector

Magic Johnson and David Robinson ON CARD autos

OzCardTrader

No Glove, No love.

Magic Johnson and David Robinson ON CARD autos

OzCardTrader

OzCardTrader

OzCardTrader

kobemania

Walt Frazier Collector

Privacy & Transparency

Privacy & Transparency