FOR SALE THREADS...no price....frustrating
- Thread starter crows2010
- Start date
Similar cards is not the same as the card you are holding. Take Verse and his MJ buyback 1/1 for instance. How the hell do you value that. In the end he put it on the bay for a High BIN asking for OFFERS and he ended up getting a much higher offer than other people on other forums said it was worth or what they would pay.
hawksforever
Magic Fan
I agree with having a taking offer prefix for threads, kind of like For Sale or For Trade. If someone wants offers only on a card what is the problem with that? It is their card and their choice, if you don't like the way they are doing it then don't buy or offer. I just feel that having a prefix of this stops the problem. People who dont like offers know which threads to avoid and those that dont care can go have a look.
This is what champs my bit, "This card is worth $xx", cards do not have set values, they might have a value that the majority sell at for a period of time but we are dealing with something with little instrinsic value. They are worth what people are willing to pay and values can rise and fall constantly. NO CARD has a set price, they have a range which they have recently sold for but that is all and often they will move higher through this range if a player becomes suddenly popular. It always amuses me when people try and tell me what a cards value is.
This is what champs my bit, "This card is worth $xx", cards do not have set values, they might have a value that the majority sell at for a period of time but we are dealing with something with little instrinsic value. They are worth what people are willing to pay and values can rise and fall constantly. NO CARD has a set price, they have a range which they have recently sold for but that is all and often they will move higher through this range if a player becomes suddenly popular. It always amuses me when people try and tell me what a cards value is.
hawksforever
Magic Fan
Crows2010, You are way off track and to be honest have a lack of understanding of how and why transactions occur. You do make a point earlier about all the Offer Me threads but don't underpin your original strong comments with pointless ramblings (no offence) because what you are saying now IMO is making you look imature and have little idea of what you are talking about.
Mate all I was doing was using it as an example where asking for offers is more than acceptable and how a price cannot be placed on certain cards no matter what you say. Remember you started this thread originally asking for prices only in the FS section and all I am doing is showing how both are warranted.
the price of a card is based (in my opinion) on 4 things Hopefully I will get this in the right order
1. Scarcity...obviously 1/1 demand big dollars as does signature cards because there are less made blah blah blah
2.How bad does someone want it.....Read on a forum a while ago somebody paid $26 for a port power team set, must have wanted that sucker real bad
3.Circumstance..Did he die, did he win a Brownlow, he doesn't sign cards etc etc etc
4.Condition...did this last obviously..if I wanted a 1/1 of dead player really bad I don't care about the condition
I take this into consideration when "buying" so I dont give a rats how much you paid for it or where you got it from etc. so in short tell me the price you want if not don't waste my time. If you want an offer do it like Ebay put your price on it and then best offer after it.
1. Scarcity...obviously 1/1 demand big dollars as does signature cards because there are less made blah blah blah
2.How bad does someone want it.....Read on a forum a while ago somebody paid $26 for a port power team set, must have wanted that sucker real bad
3.Circumstance..Did he die, did he win a Brownlow, he doesn't sign cards etc etc etc
4.Condition...did this last obviously..if I wanted a 1/1 of dead player really bad I don't care about the condition
I take this into consideration when "buying" so I dont give a rats how much you paid for it or where you got it from etc. so in short tell me the price you want if not don't waste my time. If you want an offer do it like Ebay put your price on it and then best offer after it.
hawksforever
Magic Fan
No it wasnt, but looks like you are up for an agrument, I dont see the point. So I will leave this alone.
You are spot on with everything you've said here but it just comes down to a simply theory of supply and demand and all the factors you listed above influence this
if you want a term to cover all four points of my staement that would be it "supply and demand" but we also see now a shortage of foods due to The floods so once again supply and demand kicks in and up go the prices, which I don't have a problem with, but at least the shops are still putting prices on their food not a sign saying make me an offer
