EBay Seller of the Month

[DK Trading Cards]

Who ever bought the 2006 invincible legends set should own up and take the cards to select for authenticity or secondhand_cardboard_dealerb should own up and prove there legit

 

[Fleer_retro_collector_aus]

Who ever bought the 2006 invincible legends set should own up and take the cards to select for authenticity or secondhand_cardboard_dealerb should own up and prove there legit

Who is this secondhand_cardboard_dealer any one know?

 

[Wizzle]

#014 smith sold on eBay yesterday, strange that Colesy has #014 in his collection! Honest mistake with number/scam/two #014's?

 

[DK Trading Cards]

Owen did u buy the dynamic set off the same bloke ?
If you did ask him for the certificate of authenticity letter dynamic gives you when there all the same number !

 

[DK Trading Cards]

#014 smith sold on eBay yesterday, strange that Colesy has #014 in his collection! Honest mistake with number/scam/two #014's?

Of what card are we talking about wizzle ?

 

[BruzDB]

Of what card are we talking about wizzle ?

This one I think.

http://www.ebay.com.au/itm/2014-ESP...zeXxqzNVLfkM4JYXJRA2w%3D&orig_cvip=true&rt=nc

 

[the game rugby league]

#014 smith sold on eBay yesterday, strange that Colesy has #014 in his collection! Honest mistake with number/scam/two #014's?

Has colesy sold it as he was buying a car

 

[Wizzle]

Has colesy sold it as he was buying a car

Checked with him
100% still has it

 

[hobo]

There is to much variation in the numbers and signature from dynamic. It was the same with the diecut legend set that was sold by the same seller. I have never seen the gold numbers printed out of level on any select card set ever . The numbers are out of level and spaces are to far apart. There quality control was nearly flawless and even one of the cards the 1 was not even there. Dodgy dealing going on here. I would recommend you to stay clear of this seller

I love an investigation and for me with what I'm presented with, the jury is still out. Innocent until proven guilty.

The evidence / reasonable doubt:
All this sellers other transactions have been for reasonably high end cards and they look legit, the IP signatures all look sweet to my limited knowledge, no negative feedback.

I also looked at the numbering and the reverse of the 2006 cards, even zoomed in and added grid lines and for me all those 13 are pretty consistent with each other and to my eye they appear pretty level. The gold on these often reflects light which MAY give the appearance of variable size. The spacing doesn't appear ANY different from the ones I own.

Dynamic were dodgy, anything could have happened, they are a notoriously faked card anyway. I looked at a few samples and in this release the players used differrent pens and because it was a GEM signed either side of the card (wave down left or right of the card) the few I looked at had similar looking sigs (colour and placement) and where signed on the correct side. I have heard that Dynamic had lots of "spares" so the sigs and blank COA may be legit but the numbering and completed COA not.

VERY DODGY..... .. Here is the No 13 Toovey & has been on Ebay for a while. I have spoken to the owner who is a trusted seller & he said he pulled the No 13 toovey out of case he bought back in 2006 & has reported the fakes to Select, they are currently investigating it now.
http://www.ebay.com.au/itm/SEA-EAGL...386480?pt=AU_NRL_Rugby_League_Merchandise&has

Also I have the No 13 Roach which I pulled from a case back in 2010.

Do you think this seller would be able to post a picture of the reverse of his #13 Toovey? Like they say "asked for a 13 but they drew a 31".

Cheers
Ross

 

[hobo]

Checked with him
100% still has it

There's positive feedback less than 24 hours later, very efficient.

 

[Dr Grange]

Do you think this seller would be able to post a picture of the reverse of his #13 Toovey? Like they say "asked for a 13 but they drew a 31".

Cheers
Ross

I will ask him for photo of the back of the card. He was the one who contacted Select direct himself to confirm card & Grant Cropley assured him his is legit & the ones on Ebay of Toovey & Roach are fake & have been duplicated & a few others lock dodgy.
I will scan mine tonight & post up picture of it tonight.

 

[the game rugby league]

There's positive feedback less than 24 hours later, very efficient.

Something dodgy there although the number could be a diiferent one or he just has not got the card stole the picture and is ripping someone off. We now know it is not number 14. Good pick up

 

[the game rugby league]

I love an investigation and for me with what I'm presented with, the jury is still out. Innocent until proven guilty.

The evidence / reasonable doubt:
All this sellers other transactions have been for reasonably high end cards and they look legit, the IP signatures all look sweet to my limited knowledge, no negative feedback.

I also looked at the numbering and the reverse of the 2006 cards, even zoomed in and added grid lines and for me all those 13 are pretty consistent with each other and to my eye they appear pretty level. The gold on these often reflects light which MAY give the appearance of variable size. The spacing doesn't appear ANY different from the ones I own.

Dynamic were dodgy, anything could have happened, they are a notoriously faked card anyway. I looked at a few samples and in this release the players used differrent pens and because it was a GEM signed either side of the card (wave down left or right of the card) the few I looked at had similar looking sigs (colour and placement) and where signed on the correct side. I have heard that Dynamic had lots of "spares" so the sigs and blank COA may be legit but the numbering and completed COA not.



Do you think this seller would be able to post a picture of the reverse of his #13 Toovey? Like they say "asked for a 13 but they drew a 31".

Cheers
Ross

I had a look at the numbers andto me some look out. I might have to check my eyes again. There is no getting passed that others have the no. 13 as well.

 

[Andjel 2251]

I was the one who bought the set of no. 13's from secondhand_cardboard_dealer ....They all looked legit ??
I hope this gets sorted out ??

 

[Dr Grange]

Here's the link to item so you can zoom in on cards.
http://www.ebay.com.au/itm/2006-Inv...D&orig_cvip=true&rt=nc&_trksid=p2047675.l2557

 

[Wizzle]

Something dodgy there although the number could be a diiferent one or he just has not got the card stole the picture and is ripping someone off. We now know it is not number 14. Good pick up

Unless there is two #014's?

 

[DK Trading Cards]

I was the one who bought the set of no. 13's from secondhand_cardboard_dealer ....They all looked legit ??
I hope this gets sorted out ??

Ring select Australia champ they will sort it out with you to confirm the authenticity of these cards

 

[Dr Grange]

HERE IT IS YOU BE THE JUDGE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

 

[the game rugby league]

I was the one who bought the set of no. 13's from secondhand_cardboard_dealer ....They all looked legit ??
I hope this gets sorted out ??

I would ask for my money back have a good look at Geoff toovey it has its numbers all over the place. Just checked my set no no.13 thank you lord

 

[Fleer_retro_collector_aus]

What i don't understand is this if these are fake and the numbers are all over the place if this was to be photo shopped wouldn't you think the numbers be spot on and not all over the place.
Just puting it out there