Courier Mail's Top 25 players of 2009

[#1 Eels fan]

they could have given thurston extra points for his wonderful technique in head kicking Sorry matty

 

[mattbowen]

I dont care Dave

If you dont want him, dont buy him. We'll keep the best Halfback in the world ATM then Thanks.

And I bet if it was reversed, Smith couldnt do what JT does with the Cowboys.

 

[Diggaz TC]

Smith couldn't guide the Cowboys to 12th on the table?

 

[mattbowen]

??? You never know. Cowboys would probably guide Smith to 12th

 

[thenamesgould]

Thurston at 9th is about the one bit that does seem correct. He had a poor year for the Cowboys. I'd have Kimmorley and Prince ahead of him in the halfback stakes.

I'd still have Inglis at number one. Despite Melbourne being a great side with many great players, look at the effect it had when he missed two games through suspension. Couldn't buy a win!

Gidley wasn't even the Knights best player this year, where is Zeb Taia? Gidley looked very tired after Origin, lost his trademark zip and wasn't as effective.

 

[mattbowen]

Prince ahead of Thurston?

Is that right?

 

[Ethan the Eel]

Can list our own top 25 and see what we come up with as a combined group. Still need to think of mine. Am a Parra supporter but still think Thurston is number 1 player in the game. Will confer with Ethan the Eel in the morning and come up with our top 25. He'll probably put Todd Lowrie in his fav player. We will see.

David (Ethan the Eel's dad)

 

[#1 Eels fan]

This is my top 25 but i could not put a number next to them as they are all no 1

Luke Burt
Nathan Cayless
Joe Galuvao
Eric Grothe
Weller Hauraki
Jarryd Hayne
Nathan Hindmarsh
Krisnan Inu
Kris Keating
Matthew Keating
Kevin Kingston
Jeremy Latimore
Todd Lowrie
Tim Mannah
Feleti Mateo
Fuifui Moimoi
Daniel Mortimer
Brendan Oake
Joel Reddy
Tim Robinson
Jeff Robson
Ben Smith
Taulima Tautai
Broderick Wright
Jonathan Wright

Hang on a Minute:-k its Parramatta Eels NRL Squad!!!!!
yes well it is as they are #1

 

[GiRDS-]

NO THEY ARE #2, melnourne storm are just unbeatable with the likes of TONY ARCHER amongst inglis slater and smith in their team lol

 

[#1 Eels fan]

"shiver" Oh yeh ARCHER

 

[Jets59]

where is wille mason and shaun kenny dowell in that top 25..............lol.