Courier Mail's Top 25 players of 2009

mattbowen

Cowboys Collector
Feedback - 95.2%
20   1   0
No. 25 Josh Dugan - Raiders
Brilliant rookie who transferred his Toyota Cup form to the big stage.

No. 24 Luke O'Donnell - Cowboys
Powerful lock who was arguably the Cowboys' best performer this season.

No. 23 Corey Parker - Broncos
Hard working back rower who played all but nine minutes of the Broncos season.

No. 22 Gareth Ellis - Tigers
The English import proved his class producing a memorable for season in the NRL.

No. 21 Trent Waterhouse - Panthers
After a number of seasons disrupted by injury returned to his devastating best.

No. 20 Ben Hannant - Bulldogs
Enjoyed a stellar year at the Bulldogs and was also heroic playing while hurt for Queensland.

No. 19 Scott Prince - Titans
Didn't scale the heights of last season, but was still one of the most energetic playmakers in the competition.

No. 18 Ben Creagh - Dragons
Had a superb season on the Dragons' left fringe and took that form with him to the Origin arena.

No. 17 Kurt Gidley - Knights
Heart and soul performer for Newcastle who can be as brilliant as he is tough.

No. 16 Preston Campbell - Titans
Ageless game breaker who shows no sign of slowing down.

No. 15 Robbie Farrah - Tigers
Was consistently a handful and broke into rep football this season.

No. 14 Sam Thaiday - Broncos
Delivered his most consistent season at all levels of competition and rewarded with a Test spot.

No. 13 Michael Ennis - Bulldogs
Together with Kimmorley, powered the Bulldogs from the outhouse to the penthouse.

No. 12 Michael Jennings - Panthers
Electric speedster who enjoyed a break-out year in the NRL.

No. 11 Anthony Watmough - Sea Eagles
Damaging backrower who was Manly's best performer of the season.

No. 10 Nathan Friend - Titans
Responded to attempts by his club to sign high-priced hookers from elsewhere by delivering his finest season in the NRL. Was the Titans' most consistent performer and added extra attacking potency to his outstanding defence.

No. 9 Johnathan Thurston - Cowboys
Didn't have his best season, particularly for his club side, but remains a class act. The Cowboys will be desperate to keep him in their corral beyond the end of next season.

No. 8 Jamie Soward - Dragons
Would have been disappointed by how the Dragons finished the year, but enjoyed a breakout campaign in the NRL and was responsible for some of the most entertaining attacking raids of the regular season.

No. 7 Fuifui Moimoi - Eels
Emerging as the most damaging front rower in the game, his try in the grand final was typical of the spectacular bash and barge efforts he produced regularly for Parramatta this season

No. 6 Cameron Smith - Storm
The skipper of premiership-winning Storm, Smith again proved why he is considered the top hooker in the game. While his efforts aren't as spectacular as others in the top 10, he is vital to Melbourne, Queensland and Australia.

No. 5 Brett Kimmorley - Bulldogs
The veteran halfback was recharged by the switch to Belmore, winding back the clock to deliver a vintage campaign. Also played strongly when recalled to the Blues Origin squad. His importance to the Dogs was emphasised by their struggles when he was absent with a fractured cheekbone.

No. 4 Darren Lockyer - Broncos
The Broncos skipper underlined his standing as one of the code's premier players as he masterminded his club's late-season revival that ended one game short of the grand final. On the the verge of signing a new two-year deal to play out his career at Red Hill and has plenty left to give.

No. 3 Greg Inglis - Storm
A deserving recipient of representative player of the year honours, Inglis also showed his class for Melbourne in the biggest games of the year. His combination of power and raw speed is captivating.

No. 2 Jarryd Hayne - Eels
Rugby league has much to thank Fiji for, with Hayne's career surging to spectacular new heights after his humbling experience in camp with the Pacific Island minnows at last year's World Cup. Some of the stuff the Dally M Medallist produced as he almost single-handled propelled Parramatta to the grand final was unbelievable

No. 1 Billy Slater - Storm
The reigning RLIF player of the year was challenged strongly from a number of fronts this year, but responded as champions should. Finished with another State of Origin title, a premiership, the Clive Churchill Medal and an impressive highlight reel. There is no better, or more consistent, game breaker in the business.


I dont agree with this. What do you guys think?
 
I agree. And why is JT 9th when I think he was about 3rd best player. And ho was Cam Smith better than Johnathan Thurston. WTF!
 
mate

girds is right

The courier mail has such a biased opinion putting Lockyer at 4th

we all know the late season revival was sparked by Dave Taylor, and anyone who doesnt admit to that .

Well rugby league isnt the sport for them :) :) :)

too many Lockyer arse kissers if u ask me.

One of his worst seasons to date in my opinion, didnt spark or revive ****!!!
 
yeh he had his worst season i a while. i agree with hayne and slater but i think grothe should be in their to

---------- Post added 12-10-2009 at 10:13 PM ----------

and even wendeel sailor
 
i dont think that list could possibly be right.....Lockyer 4th was it for that dive he took:lol::lol::lol:

really!!! some of those guys imo should not be on there
 
1- Lockyer shouldnt realy be there at all.
2- Why is Thurston 9th?
3- Friend at 10. He was good but not THAT good. And ahead of Ennis. WHy wasnt he Hooker of the year then ?
4- Gareth Ellis?
5- WHy is Scott Prince there? What did he even do this year?
6- Cam Smith at 6?
7- Why is kimmorley 5th. He was good but not ahead of Thurston. Why wasnt he Halfback of the year then?

:mad::mad::mad::mad::mad:
 
Yeh, thats what i mean this list is crap imo as some of the players of the year are worse of than there positional counterparts :blink:and some should not even be on there!!! Rubbish i say:lol::lol: utter RUBBISH:whistle::lol:
 
I agree. And why is JT 9th when I think he was about 3rd best player. And ho was Cam Smith better than Johnathan Thurston. WTF!

I love your whole hearted passion for JT it cracks me up.....Cam Smith guided the Storm to a Premiership, JT guided the Cowboys to 12th........that would be one good reason. :D

Gareth Ellis had a great season and I bet any tiger supporter out there would agree....I think he was even Club player of the Year for them.

Ross
 
JT was more dominent then Smith though. And it wasnt JUST Smith leading the Storm.

But it was JUST Thurston leading the Cowboys.

And why didnt Smith get Hooker of the year?
 
Ennis is a perfect example. Generally he isn't popular because he is known as a bit of a grub. However, at the Dally M's the voters became infatuated with the Bulldogs and he somehow was given Hooker of the Year despite the fact that he wasn't even the hooker with the highest vote count for the Dally M award.
 
Proof that JT was better than Cam Smith as well!!!! He got more Dally M points. He came second which means he should really be the second best player of the year, behind Hayne
 
Proof that JT was better than Cam Smith as well!!!! He got more Dally M points. He came second which means he should really be the second best player of the year, behind Hayne

Votes and statistics can be used to prove or disprove just about anything...for example with your theory above this just proves (as you said in an earlier post) that the Cowboys were so poor that JT was the only one receiving votes.....Smith played in a team of superstars....votes get shared...therefor much more deserving of the accolades.;)

So in theory you could divide JT's votes by 17. moving him out of even the Courier Mails biassed list. :lol: :lol:

Ross
 
Back
Top Bottom