Australian Idol Season IV

axeman23 · Sep 18, 2006

So who got voted out tonight? I was watching a DVD so I missed the verdict... Also, it seems like there's 2 16yr-old girls in the comp by some of the replies here? Who's Lisa, and who's Jessica? The only names I really know are Mutto (how could you forget), Klancie (the country girl), Levina, Bobby, and the other names are a bit fuzzy...

the_pie · Sep 18, 2006

axeman23 said:
So who got voted out tonight? I was watching a DVD so I missed the verdict... Also, it seems like there's 2 16yr-old girls in the comp by some of the replies here? Who's Lisa, and who's Jessica? The only names I really know are Mutto (how could you forget), Klancie (the country girl), Levina, Bobby, and the other names are a bit fuzzy...

Reigan Derry got voted out Lisa is the one who's small, has a voice like missy higgins, sorta monotoned, whereas jessica is the one from darwin, booming voice, smiles a lot, actually think she turned 17 the other week

JZA · Sep 18, 2006

jimboiitmac said:
Anyhow, that's my opinion. I don't know how much musical background you guys have got, but I got to 7th Grade Piano, 4th Grade Clarinet and have had singing coaching as well.

Ive sung since i was 5, played guitar since i was 8, can play drums, bass, and a bit of piano as well...doesnt mean my opinion is more valid than yours or anyone elses.

i dislike jess and lavina cos theyre voices are not original in the slightest, technically perhaps they have the finest voices but its been done to death, there's a couple of girls who sound like them in idol every single year. they have too narrow a range, their specialty is diva's like celine/whitney and thats it.

axeman23 · Sep 18, 2006

the_pie said:
Reigan Derry got voted out Lisa is the one who's small, has a voice like missy higgins, sorta monotoned, whereas jessica is the one from darwin, booming voice, smiles a lot, actually think she turned 17 the other week

Ah, ok... Thanks for the help, champ! So Jessica's the young'un I like, Lisa's the one I'm not too keen on... And is Reigan the farm-girl, or the other chick?

the_pie · Sep 18, 2006

axeman23 said:
Ah, ok... Thanks for the help, champ! So Jessica's the young'un I like, Lisa's the one I'm not too keen on... And is Reigan the farm-girl, or the other chick?

Curly haired one, the farm girl is Klancie...Jeez i know way too much about idol #-o I actually went to 3 shows last yr

axeman23 · Sep 18, 2006

JZA said:
Ive sung since i was 5, played guitar since i was 8, can play drums, bass, and a bit of piano as well...doesnt mean my opinion is more valid than yours or anyone elses.

i dislike jess and lavina cos theyre voices are not original in the slightest, technically perhaps they have the finest voices but its been done to death, there's a couple of girls who sound like them in idol every single year. they have too narrow a range, their specialty is diva's like celine/whitney and thats it.

I can kind of see the point about the "diva" thing, but IMO, that's actually the hardest stuff to do, the high, drawn-out notes... As for wanting something a bit different, I can respect that also, but for me I'd prefer something that's gonna blow my socks off (Levina/Jess), rather than something "easy on the ears and a bit different" (Lisa/4KQ lol...) But yeah, at least in my eyes, someone like Lisa will get a good reaction from most straight off the bat with the whole "cute and vulnerable" thing, which also puts me off. Add that to the fact the judges keep gushing "I can't believe you're only 16, so fragile, so different and blah,blah,blah, while when a young guy came on who they thought should be 10-foot tall and bullet-proof (Joseph), they cut him down for the same reasons they praise her...

axeman23 · Sep 18, 2006

the_pie said:
Curly haired one, the farm girl is Klancie...Jeez i know way too much about idol #-o I actually went to 3 shows last yr

Thanks again, champ! Yeah, actually she was a nice bit of eye-candy, but if I'm judging just on pure singing talent, she'd be out before too long anyway...

Magicman · Sep 18, 2006

ok heres Magicmans hot tip lol:

Reigan you are hot bad luck honey!!

Lisa, Jess, Damien and Dean will be the last 4.

Lisa has a unique voice, will sell aheap of CD's....

Benny J · Sep 19, 2006

Lisa....is crap. She is too nervous. Her voice is not what everyone is saying it is IMO!! She is a crap performer.

Mutto and Ricky shouldnt have been in the bottom three last night....and Reigen deserved to go for singing something noone knows.

Surely the contestants realise that this is just as much a popularity contest as it is a singing contest.....which is why the likes of Chris, Bobby, Damien, Dean and Jess will do well!! Cause they have big personalilites....and can sing

Funkadelic · Sep 19, 2006

I don't watch Idol but just reading the paper, whats this about Kyle telling Jessica she has to lose the jelly belly?

Benny J · Sep 19, 2006

Funkadelic said:
I don't watch Idol but just reading the paper, whats this about Kyle telling Jessica she has to lose the jelly belly?

Yep...and it was funny. Dont get me wrong, i dont agree with telling 16 year olds they are fat...but we were all thinking it!!

jimboiitmac · Sep 19, 2006

shame on Reigan leaving, a great talent.

Magicman · Sep 19, 2006

DVS - i wasnt? didnt even notice it actually lol.....

JZA · Sep 19, 2006

its just shit stirring for ratings, jess looks fine i reckon, not overweight at all. maybe a bit of baby fat but thats natural for a 16 yr old girl.

the funniest thing is that it came from the tubby bitch kyle...hypocritical much? :roll:

Benny J · Sep 19, 2006

JZA said:
its just shit stirring for ratings, jess looks fine i reckon, not overweight at all. maybe a bit of baby fat but thats natural for a 16 yr old girl.

the funniest thing is that it came from the tubby bitch kyle...hypocritical much? :roll:

Agreed....but at the same time i think he is right.

Unfortunatley it is the way the general "society" is and if she was to win or go close she would critisized for her weight (not that i agree, as i think she looks fine) the same way Casey Donovan was/is.#-o

Like i said i dont agree with it, but as i have mentioned in a previous post, IDOL is just as much a beauty/popularity contest as it is a singing contest which is why Dean is considered one of the favourites to win.....

MetallicA' · Sep 22, 2006

Reigan shouldnt of left for singing Karnivool.
I thought she was awesome, great talent and a metal head at heart, good to see.
My favs are Mutto, Damien and Jessica.
I think Damien last two songs have been bloody awesome. The one he sang last week was so awesome it left me with goosebumps.

Australian Idol Season IV

axeman23

OzCardTrader

the_pie

OzCardTrader

JZA

the ginger ninja

axeman23

OzCardTrader

the_pie

OzCardTrader

axeman23

OzCardTrader

axeman23

OzCardTrader

Magicman

Banned User

Benny J

Mr Big Shot...

Funkadelic

On Again, Off Again..

Benny J

Mr Big Shot...

jimboiitmac

miami pride

Magicman

Banned User

JZA

the ginger ninja

Benny J

Mr Big Shot...

MetallicA'

Ricky Davis Collector

Australian Idol Season IV

OzCardTrader

OzCardTrader

the ginger ninja

OzCardTrader

OzCardTrader

OzCardTrader

OzCardTrader

Banned User

Mr Big Shot...

On Again, Off Again..

Mr Big Shot...

miami pride

Banned User

the ginger ninja

Mr Big Shot...

Ricky Davis Collector

Privacy & Transparency

Privacy & Transparency