Mal!
Not an immortal but should be
Man, interest seems to be at rock bottom for Traders this year, going by the number of posts in this thread!
Can't say I blame people, I'm feeling the same way, pretty much. I think maybe a bit too much coming out has just fatigued me for the whole hobby ...
Ok here are my thoughts......
Girds is spot on here, this is about giving the dealers something to resell and is aimed at people needing to open much more product to complete sets. This is the release where ESP makes its biggest profits so it makes sense for them to make this the product where people need to open a lot of stock to get cards to fill gaps.
If you look at the per box breakdown and the potential value:
Per Box (Assuming its still one parallel per pack along with another insert)
- 36 Parallel Cards ($1 each Resale) $36
- 12 Special Parallel Cards ($3 Dollars each Resale) $36
- 12 Faces of the Game ($3 Dollars each Resale) $36
- 6 Season to Remember ($5 each Resale) $30
- 3 Pieces of the Puzzle ($8 each Resale) $24
- 2 Thunder and Lightning ($12 each Resale) $24
- 1 Galactic Heroes ($15 each Resale) $15
- 1 Retirement or Club Leaders ($25 each Resale) $25
Total Estimated Resale Value is $226 per box.
You are also looking at 2 hits per pack. With the insert sets being so big it will help retain some value.
Overall it looks a good release with plenty to collect, with the only head scratcher for me being the Dynamic Duo only having 3 cards, this could have been spread across all teams as a good chase card.
Cheers
Matt
All you have said may be true, but esp may see in a few years, hindsight, if they do not want to that is, they have flooded the market and driving collectors out of the market with there silly repetition of parallels and constant use of the same image.Yeah this is 100% correct!
Its the best traders set we have seen yet any way. Some collectors will complain about the insert sets but then this time last year theyd be complaining about not getting enough resale back on their box breaks
You cant have everything, this is very close to what i'd consider the perfect medium for both collectors and dealers.
I hope I'm not an old fart as you put it, we all have opinions, and this is a site where we are able to share them.I agree with all your thoughts, Matt. The last two sets of Traders have provided a much better product for collectors in terms of what is in a box. In addition to this the 2014 Elite release was absolutely terrific (would still like a case hit, but very, very good nonetheless)
The problem for me in Traders is scarcity. they are so mass produced that a 4 per box Triple Threat from 2013 Elite is twice as scarce as a 1 in every 24 boxes Four Brothers card from 2014 Traders.
I think it is a matter of perspective. I think if people didn't have the carrot of the legend sig in Traders and it was moved to Elite as a case hit then people wouldn't be so disappointed with Traders. It would be the cheap and cheerful set to start the year, with heaps of inserts etc. Scarcity and value wouldn't be so much of an issue. You wouldn't have high end cards lost to kids who don't have the means to look after them safely. You'd just be collecting because it is fun to collect. That would lower the price, which I feel is far too high for what the set is. I think they need to produce a product in which the box can sell for around the $90-95 mark. Alternately, I think the Elite set is remarkably cheap for what it is.
It is important to look at the high end cards in Traders as a bonus I guess rather than the be all and end all of the set. But is very, very hard not to be disappointed when you can't seem to get one.
I personally have stopped collecting because the answer to the question 'can i complete all the sets that come out' is no. But that is because I am a complete set collector. There are other types of collectors that I'd imagine are very satisfied. People are leaving, but the mass produced aspect of the set is no doubt attracting another legion of fans who will no doubt grow up, get jobs and drive the hobby forward. The sets can't please everyone, and I don't think you can judge a releases success on just the opinion of old farts on the OZCT site.
People say that Dynamic over-produced, but they got me hooked.