POTM & Redemptions ~~ January POTM Nomination Thread ~~

[smc2910]

Re: ~~~~~~ January POTM Nomination Thread ~~~~~~

Closed for nominations.

 

[smc2910]

Re: ~~~~~~ January POTM Nomination Thread ~~~~~~

Ok, also thought id give this a bump to see if anyone had any more thoughts about opening up the comp to allow Redemptions

 

[nathanblack]

Why not allow the redemption in the month it arrives? Like the Kobe signed Bball. Excluded for January but include it when he gets it? As long as it was pulled not purchased. Seems fair. We need to see the actual card sometimes or in that case basketball.

 

[ARTHY23]

is say its like memorabilia pull.. it should be alright but if its a card redemption.. it shouldnt be.. because its pretty rare that u pull a basketball out of a box of cards

 

[smc2910]

any more thoughts guys

 

[smc2910]

So

Allow redemptions in the comp as long as they are received within 2 months and can then be nominated in the month the redemption received

eg January redemption is pulled, have until 31st March for item to be received and nominated.

 

[bojob]

Sounds good to me.

 

[Shaun]

but how often are redemptions actually filled within 2 months? im yet to get one back the quick

 

[smc2910]

how long do you think ?

3 months, 6 months or no ceiling


no redemption replacement either, regardless of how sick they are

 

[kiwi_in_melb]

well panini states 4 months so how bout that?

 

[Cobretti]

thing is there is no point putting a time limit on a redemption. Because if someone pulls one. They will just hold onto it and claim they pulled it within two months of the card arriving.

 

[smc2910]

thing is there is no point putting a time limit on a redemption. Because if someone pulls one. They will just hold onto it and claim they pulled it within two months of the card arriving.

If a time limit is in place i would still need this per the rules

a Link to THREAD or VIDEO where card was pulled (By yourself or 3rd party) . Evidence must be supplied if this is not available

can just add where & when to it so i know its within 2 month

 

[Cobretti]

If a time limit is in place i would still need this per the rules

a Link to THREAD or VIDEO where card was pulled (By yourself or 3rd party) . Evidence must be supplied if this is not available

can just add where & when to it so i know its within 2 month

Yes but this can be cheated too.

I could bust my boxes. Then if I don't get any redemptions write up a thread ABOUT to bust boxes. Then put up my hits.

If I get redemptions I don't put my boxes up at all. I put the redemption in and wait for it to come. Then once redemption arrived SAY i am busting open some boxes and claim it as a hit.

granted this is extreme effort put in to do all this buy there is a SMALL chance it can happen.

 

[kiwi_in_melb]

Yes but this can be cheated too.

I could bust my boxes. Then if I don't get any redemptions write up a thread ABOUT to bust boxes. Then put up my hits.

If I get redemptions I don't put my boxes up at all. I put the redemption in and wait for it to come. Then once redemption arrived SAY i am busting open some boxes and claim it as a hit.

granted this is extreme effort put in to do all this buy there is a SMALL chance it can happen.

There is probably a small chance of this happening already with the way the redemption rule stands at the moment.

However surely 95% of people on here wouldnt go to that much effort just for the chance of getting $20 - $30 off a box??? and with the quality of the pulls coming out of boxes in these comps already MOST of the redemption stuff isnt good enough to win anyway