POTM & Redemptions ~~ January POTM Nomination Thread ~~

Re: ~~~~~~ January POTM Nomination Thread ~~~~~~

I have no chance but...

DSC01705.jpg
[/IMG]

/49
http://www.ozcardtrader.com.au/forum/live-box-breaks-basketball/91392-1-pack-update-1-pack-prestige.html#post842624
 
Re: ~~~~~~ January POTM Nomination Thread ~~~~~~

Last night for nominations

Will close these up tomorrow morning and get the voting thread up later tomorrow night.
 
Re: ~~~~~~ January POTM Nomination Thread ~~~~~~

Am i too late for the comp Shaun? Does the Kobe ball qualify or are redemptions out?
 
Re: ~~~~~~ January POTM Nomination Thread ~~~~~~

well I got no problem with it as a basketballs arnt something you pull regularly. So it would be hard to do a POTM basketball comp
 
Re: ~~~~~~ January POTM Nomination Thread ~~~~~~

Sorry Nick :(

7. Redemptions do not qualify for nomination Unless item is redeemed and received within the month


been one of the rules from the start

but guess we can find out if members want that rule changed since there has been a few nice cards in last few months that missed out ???

would need to be a decent majority of people wanting the change.
 
Re: ~~~~~~ January POTM Nomination Thread ~~~~~~

well i think it is worth brining it up.. Because the amount of redemptions panini has is annoying.

Sad part is with a redemption you don't get to see the card. But I would be cool if an image was supplied from elsewhere to show what it looks like (ie panini website if they even have image checklists haha).

Obviously people know what a ball looks like.
 
Re: ~~~~~~ January POTM Nomination Thread ~~~~~~

Seeing as all of paninis hits are going to be redemptions shortly i think this rule needs to be looked at. maybe add a months grace to them especially in cases like this where its been pulled with a couple of hours to go in the month so if it was redeemed and in hand with by the end of next month it would be eligable for febs potm or being more realistic if it was in hand by march eligable for marchs potm but i guess its hard to say whats the best time frame
 
Re: ~~~~~~ January POTM Nomination Thread ~~~~~~

Yeah totally agree with Kiwi above a month or two grace for redemptions as that ball Nick pulled is SICK. Maybe introduce the rule from next month onwards.
 
Re: ~~~~~~ January POTM Nomination Thread ~~~~~~

Seeing as all of paninis hits are going to be redemptions shortly i think this rule needs to be looked at. maybe add a months grace to them especially in cases like this where its been pulled with a couple of hours to go in the month so if it was redeemed and in hand with by the end of next month it would be eligable for febs potm or being more realistic if it was in hand by march eligable for marchs potm but i guess its hard to say whats the best time frame

+1. :thumbsup:
 
Re: ~~~~~~ January POTM Nomination Thread ~~~~~~

Yeah im cool if its not acceptable, maybe the idea of redemptions being eligible when they arrive in hand might be the go since as said there seems to be alot more redemptions of late.
 
Re: ~~~~~~ January POTM Nomination Thread ~~~~~~

good idea let them in the comp when they arrive. That way you get to see the real item and vote on its merit.

After all they did bust them. So card in hand is equivalent to a bust haha.
 
Re: ~~~~~~ January POTM Nomination Thread ~~~~~~

yeh redemptions should be valid for the month that they arrived in your hand, not the month the original redemption card was pulled because as you all know...these can sometimes be a year apart!
 
Back
Top Bottom