Select Prestige SP #2

[Farmer2Goggin2Wade]

5 Geelongs. Hopefully a coach card too.

 

[BrownKing]

Didnt LeCras score about 60 goals last year? How on earth was he overlooked for Leon Davis? Reminds me a couple of years ago when Robbo kicked 70 odd goals and didnt get a berth in the side.

Presti would have been the worst player ever to make the AA side if he hadve been in.

His selection wasnt as bad as the Harley and Mooney inclusions a few years ago.....

They were ridiculous

 

[Warney]

yeah LeCras scored around 60 goals last year, as a small forward playing in the pocket! Leon had a pretty good season but i think LeCras had a better one!

 

[crg0084]

This seems to be turning into a bag collingwood AA selection thread i agree that Maxwell should not have been in but Swan and Davis had great seasons Davis run through the middle last year. And Prestie was extremely unlucky to miss out

 

[Farmer2Goggin2Wade]

His selection wasnt as bad as the Harley and Mooney inclusions a few years ago.....

They were ridiculous

You serious about Harley? Led his team to 21-1! Is that not worthy of All-Australian selection.

 

[BrownKing]

You serious about Harley? Led his team to 21-1! Is that not worthy of All-Australian selection. [/QUOTE

Bartel/Corey/Scarlett etc led Geelong to 21-1.

Harley is a 3rd tall having no influence on games and often taking the decoy aka HFF. Sure he may stop a couple of attacking forays a game, but AA please...

How he could make an AA team is beyond me.

 

[blocka2004]

harley was ranked number 1 at marks from opposition kicks and marks inside defensive 50for that year maybe you should look at the stats before comments like that.

 

[Wheeldude]

harley was ranked number 1 at marks from opposition kicks and marks inside defensive 50for that year maybe you should look at the stats before comments like that.

Please make vids of your break mate!

 

[BrownKing]

harley was ranked number 1 at marks from opposition kicks and marks inside defensive 50for that year maybe you should look at the stats before comments like that.

and? Your saying he should be selected AA based on opposition kicks?
He does nothing the other way and is 100% defensive minded.
Marks from opposition kicks should not justify a selection.

and yeh please vid your breaks!

 

[Farmer2Goggin2Wade]

He does nothing the other way and is 100% defensive minded.

I think that has something to do with him being a defender!

 

[Warney]

I think that has something to do with him being a defender!

very true, i reckon he deserved it.

But can anyone justify LeCras not getting picked? Confused me a little

 

[BrownKing]

I think that has something to do with him being a defender!

Modern Day football equal line running.
Defenders are required to attack aswell as defend
This is why Enright and Mackie Are so succesfull
Harley did not to line running

 

[crg0084]

very true, i reckon he deserved it.

But can anyone justify LeCras not getting picked? Confused me a little

When u can only pick 22 out of hundreds of players there are going to be hard luck stories every year mate. Prestie and Mitch Clark where just as unlucky and lecras

 

[Sacha]

Sneak Peek 3 is out, Looks like a DRAFT pick card, and it is 1:72....

 

[adz2332]

link to the pic plz mate?

 

[Sacha]

No link, its on the Select email Newsletter.

 

[adz2332]

hmmm so there back to platinum draft picks to 100 like in 2008?
not bad i guess.. depends if they have done anything with the draft pics or they will keep it again to the top 17

 

[crg0084]

Its good for the port, demons supporters but im going to be pissed if its just another series of the same sh*t

 

[Sacha]

Looks like part of the Jake Melksham Draft pick card...

 

[adz2332]

not TOM Scully?