Official Real/Fake card Thread!

[ozballer23]

Since we're on Ray Allen, here's another auction...I've got several reasons why I think this is fake, but opinions welcomed.

Ray Allen LOGOMAN Auto Logo Patch Celtic 1/1 04-05 E-XL - eBay (item 180259647603 end time Jul-06-08 12:54:15 PDT)

Thegreen ex-l's are considered 1/1s. But the fact that the auto is oncard worries me. I got a feeling that it was made to be a 1/1, but was one of the fleer auction sales, the logoman and auto may have been inserted later on...
I think this card was discussed not long ago...

 

[exzibit3]

I've seen a few other autos which are on-card from that year like this Wade auto.
DWYANE WADE 2004/05 E-XL JERSEY AUTOGRAPH AUTO /70 - eBay (item 160210182627 end time Jul-17-08 19:35:19 PDT)
But I agree, I believe its from the fleer auctions as well. The 1/1 stamp is missing which is very worrisome, and the auto doesn't look anything like a Ray Allen auto.

 

[ozballer23]

I've seen a few other autos which are on-card from that year like this Wade auto.
DWYANE WADE 2004/05 E-XL JERSEY AUTOGRAPH AUTO /70 - eBay (item 160210182627 end time Jul-17-08 19:35:19 PDT)
But I agree, I believe its from the fleer auctions as well. The 1/1 stamp is missing which is very worrisome, and the auto doesn't look anything like a Ray Allen auto.

That's right there are a few card autos, not many though. The auto does look a little dodgy, the edges where the patch is in also looks forced...

 

[christuffa]

The patch looks fubar too, check out the NBA lettering, looks like it was hand stitched by a baby rhinoceros

 

[ozballer23]

The only thing that would save that auction is the seller's feedback.

 

[tss501]

I've seen a few other autos which are on-card from that year like this Wade auto.

All cards from that set I have seen have been sticker autos. But Al would be the best judge of that.

 

[ozballer23]

All cards from that set I have seen have been sticker autos. But Al would be the best judge of that.

here's another example

04-05 E-XL Court Authentics Luol Deng Auto #ed 157/200 - eBay (item 160254255490 end time Jun-30-08 18:56:49 PDT)

 

[buyingstuffformikelee]

Not sure on this one, I have oddly enough seen this somehwhere before, but am unsure if it's because it was mentioned as a fake????

Because, these cards are supposed to contain parts of their name plates, not a tag???

Does anyone know????

Tracy McGrady Exquisite Noble Nameplates Auto 25 Tag - eBay (item 160256612757 end time Jul-07-08 17:06:04 PDT)

 

[ozballer23]

I asked about that one a while ago, was wondering what a tag was doing in a "name plate"?????

Not sure on this one, I have oddly enough seen this somehwhere before, but am unsure if it's because it was mentioned as a fake????

Because, these cards are supposed to contain parts of their name plates, not a tag???

Does anyone know????

Tracy McGrady Exquisite Noble Nameplates Auto 25 Tag - eBay (item 160256612757 end time Jul-07-08 17:06:04 PDT)

 

[buyingstuffformikelee]

I asked about that one a while ago, was wondering what a tag was doing in a "name plate"?????

Did you get a reply or answer????

I'm pretty sure it's fake, and the seller has another as part of the auto patch set.

It should be a name plate in there. Hhhmmmmmmmm.

 

[ozballer23]

At least the seller seems excited by this card, not sure how legit it is, seen plenty of "questionable" patches in this product...

08 Triple Threads Jerseys CARMELO ANTHONY 1/1 !! - eBay (item 180259497080 end time Jul-09-08 05:25:28 PDT)

 

[patterz123]

Fakey NBA Logo 1/1 ??

Topps Jersey Edition Logoman GU Patch Andre Miller 1/1 - eBay (item 220256285680 end time Jul-18-08 11:02:47 PDT)

Looks quite dodgey!

 

[Farmer2Goggin2Wade]

I was just searching eBay for NBA patches and came across this:

Vince Carter 07-08 UD Ultimate NBA Jersey Patch #18/25

What are your thoughts on the top right hand corner patch?

 

[nenjabin]

I was just searching eBay for NBA patches and came across this:

Vince Carter 07-08 UD Ultimate NBA Jersey Patch #18/25

What are your thoughts on the top right hand corner patch?

I wouldn't question that seller for a second. Perfect seller always as his 4500+ feedback 100% says!

 

[exzibit3]

What the heck is a number 3 doing in a Carmelo Anthony exquisite auto/patch card? Remember this seller's name m22eighty, I've seen some real "interesting" patches coming from him.

07 Exquisite Carmelo Anthony Limit Logos Patch Auto /50 - eBay (item 160266513285 end time Aug-04-08 18:50:08 PDT)

 

[Matt26]

What the heck is a number 3 doing in a Carmelo Anthony exquisite auto/patch card? Remember this seller's name m22eighty, I've seen some real "interesting" patches coming from him.

07 Exquisite Carmelo Anthony Limit Logos Patch Auto /50 - eBay (item 160266513285 end time Aug-04-08 18:50:08 PDT)

I think you will find that its the E from the front of the Nuggets jersey....the patch is backwards thats all.

Cheers
Matt

 

[Dr. Curlytek]

What the heck is a number 3 doing in a Carmelo Anthony exquisite auto/patch card? Remember this seller's name m22eighty, I've seen some real "interesting" patches coming from him.

07 Exquisite Carmelo Anthony Limit Logos Patch Auto /50 - eBay (item 160266513285 end time Aug-04-08 18:50:08 PDT)

Looks more like an upside-down "E" (as in Denver) to me. Denver 3's are rounded, as on AI's jersey.

 

[chaddy42]

What the heck is a number 3 doing in a Carmelo Anthony exquisite auto/patch card? Remember this seller's name m22eighty, I've seen some real "interesting" patches coming from him.

07 Exquisite Carmelo Anthony Limit Logos Patch Auto /50 - eBay (item 160266513285 end time Aug-04-08 18:50:08 PDT)

I've dealt with m22eighty a number of times...a quality seller IMO.

 

[exzibit3]

I think you will find that its the E from the front of the Nuggets jersey....the patch is backwards thats all.

Cheers
Matt

Not too sure about that Matt and DrC...

chaddy42...He's got flawless feedback and no doubt he's a good seller, but some patches I've seen from him in the past are really "interesting".

 

[nenjabin]

I've dealt with m22eighty a number of times...a quality seller IMO.

Here here. Super seller that guy. And I agree, it's an E or it's a UD stuff up of AI's 3.