Who will win?

holzbauer

Banned User

Feedback - 93.5%

72   5   0

• Jul 8, 2009

• #1

hey guys we are closing in on the AFL season now and there have been many young stars who have shown their worth this season. this years NAB rising star award is sure to be a close one. here are all the nomination to date

round 1- Daniel Rich, Brisbane
round 2- David Zaharkis, Essendon
round 3- Patrick Dangerfield, Adelaide
round 4- Jaxson Barham, Collingwood
round 5- Garry Moss, Hawthorn
round 6- Stephen Hill, Fremantle
round 7- Jack Ziebell, North Melbourne
round 8- Jarryn Geary, St Kilda
round 9- Andy Otten, Adelaide
round 10- Taylor Walker, Adelaide
round 11- Brad Dick, Collingwood
round 12- Aaron Joseph, Carlton
round 13- Tayte Pears, Essendon
round 14- Jack Grimes, Melborne

ok thats the list to date. who do you think will win and why?
personally, i think either Rich or Grimes will win

 

jacko

OzCardTrader

Feedback - 98.5%

66   1   0

• Jul 8, 2009

• #2

This may seem biased, but Rich will kill it!
GOOO Lions!

 

holzbauer

Banned User

Feedback - 93.5%

72   5   0

• Jul 8, 2009

• #3

poll up now

 

LickwidGreen

Hawthorn Hawks Collector

Feedback - 100%

168   0   0

• Jul 8, 2009

• #4

Grimes by a small margin, hes averaging like 85 supercoach points a week at the moment.
Melbourne need something cheer about this year.

 

Farmer2Goggin2Wade

R.I.P Captain Beefheart!

Feedback - 100%

113   0   0

• Jul 8, 2009

• #5

LickwidGreen said:

Grimes by a small margin, hes averaging like 85 supercoach points a week at the moment.
Melbourne need something cheer about this year.

Click to expand...

98.

Yeah I think Grimes or Rich like most.

 

adz2332

OzCardTrader

Feedback - 100%

24   0   0

• Jul 8, 2009

• #6

I think grimes will take it out.

Shame Hamish Hartlett has had some injuries. He was looking very good for the power. And if he can get back for injury he'll get nominated

 

Power2009

OzCardTrader

Feedback - 100%

3   0   0

• Jul 8, 2009

• #7

I gave my vote to Rich has had an outstanding season

 

holzbauer

Banned User

Feedback - 93.5%

72   5   0

• Jul 8, 2009

• #8

adz2332 said:

I think grimes will take it out.

Shame Hamish Hartlett has had some injuries. He was looking very good for the power. And if he can get back for injury he'll get nominated

Click to expand...

yeah he was looking good, hopefully he gets back soon and plays some good footy

 

J

juddcollector

Juddy & UFC collector

Feedback - 100%

83   0   0

• Jul 8, 2009

• #9

As usual West Coast is ignored with Natinuie having no nominations but Rich is odds on

 

adz2332

OzCardTrader

Feedback - 100%

24   0   0

• Jul 8, 2009

• #10

Mate Natinuie has played 3 games for 3 kicks?? which game did he deserve a nom in???

 

TheCardMan

Cardboard addicted

Feedback - 100%

470   0   0

• Jul 8, 2009

• #11

Rich without a doubt... a bloody gun

Naituni.... will be a gun, but isnt anything overly impressive so far

 

JNM

OzCardTrader

Feedback - 100%

16   0   0

• Jul 8, 2009

• #12

Rich will win it I think, with Otten and Pears as smokies.

 

holzbauer

Banned User

Feedback - 93.5%

72   5   0

• Jul 8, 2009

• #13

yeah nic nat has done some good things but hasnt put a whole game together, i was at the port vs lions game, and the courage rich showed is amazing, he just went for it and didnt care if he got cleaned up, then went back into the middle with no fuss at all
will be a superstar

 

K

kingjack

Dane Swan super collector.

Feedback - 100%

272   0   0

• Jul 8, 2009

• #14

id have to go with rich too

personally hate the lions but rich is a good player

 

jacko

OzCardTrader

Feedback - 98.5%

66   1   0

• Jul 8, 2009

• #15

What do the lions do that makes you hate them? *Shows baffled expression*

 

holzbauer

Banned User

Feedback - 93.5%

72   5   0

• Jul 8, 2009

• #16

looks like rich has this one wrapped up!!

 

Warney

Number 20.

Feedback - 100%

57   0   0

• Jul 9, 2009

• #17

adz2332 said:

Mate Natinuie has played 3 games for 3 kicks?? which game did he deserve a nom in???

Click to expand...

Bull crap mate you've got no idea what u are talking about

 

crows2010

OzCardTrader

Feedback - 100%

119   0   0

• Jul 9, 2009

• #18

haha there is no way Grimes will win it.

1. Rich
2. Otten

daylight

3. Grimes
4. Dangerfield

---------- Post added at 09:48 AM ---------- Previous post was at 09:46 AM ----------

SKWARNE23 said:

Bull crap mate you've got no idea what u are talking about

Click to expand...

Natinui has not even come CLOSE to winning a nomination so far.

He probably will win one before the end of the year but he has zero chance of winning the award this year.

 

Warney

Number 20.

Feedback - 100%

57   0   0

• Jul 9, 2009

• #19

crows2009 said:

haha there is no way Grimes will win it.

1. Rich
2. Otten

daylight

3. Grimes
4. Dangerfield

---------- Post added at 09:48 AM ---------- Previous post was at 09:46 AM ----------



Natinui has not even come CLOSE to winning a nomination so far.

He probably will win one before the end of the year but he has zero chance of winning the award this year.

Click to expand...

1. Grimes does have a chance, Otten hasn't
2. I didn't say that he should have a nomination, i said that he has more than 3 kicks.

 

crows2010

OzCardTrader

Feedback - 100%

119   0   0

• Jul 9, 2009

• #20

SKWARNE23 said:

1. Grimes does have a chance, Otten hasn't
2. I didn't say that he should have a nomination, i said that he has more than 3 kicks.

Click to expand...

Otten will come second. He would be the only guy seriously pushing Rich.

He has been the most consistent out of all the nominees but playing in the midfield, Rich gets more of the glamour etc

Have you heard the commentators when Otten has the ball? He is VERY highly rated mate and general consensus in football circles is Rich, then Otten.