Michael Jordan and Magic Johnson every time I break a box of Exquisite or All Time Greats!!!
I have literally never placed an order containing Exquisite and/or All-Time Greats and not pulled at least one Jordan or Magic.
First order I got a mini-case of 2012/13 All-Time Greats for Christmas (two for myself, one for my brother) and had a third party select my brother's box first, then I took the other two. The boxes I picked produced a Jordan auto and a Magic auto, his box had a Grant Hill auto.
With the last massive box break I ordered another 2 boxes of Exquisite (2011/12) and two more boxes of All Time Greats (2012/13) and I was really hoping to hit a nice auto of Hakeem, David Robinson, Karl Malone, Bill Russell, Larry Bird, Julius Erving or Lebron James. Basically anybody but Jordan or Magic.
I opened the two exquisite boxes and got a Jordan auto in one box and a Magic auto in the other (Jason Kidd and Iverson in the All Time Greats).
My brother was there on each of these occasions and was absolutely dumbfounded.
I won't complain too much though - I guess there are worse problems to have lol