What are the best 5 NRL cards ever?

bjs127 · Feb 26, 2012

Hi guys,

I saw this beauty on ebay yesterday - not being a big NRL fan myself at all I would think this is a big candidate for "best NRL auto ever"?

http://www.ebay.com.au/itm/2003-nrl-Select-XL-Legend-Signature-Redemption-card-Norm-Provan-Arthur-Summons-/280826375330?pt=AU_NRL_Rugby_League_Merchandise&hash=item41628e6ca2

Does this card pop up often? What price is fair or does it not pop up much so you really need to pay whatever is being asked?

I'm interested to ask the experts here: what do you rate as the top 5 NRL cards in ranking of desirability/rarity?

Pics would be great!

Brad

king megator · Feb 26, 2012

bro i think the 2009 Select NRL Captains Darren Lockyer signature card is right up in the top 5 cards of all time.... Also this might sound strange but if you can get a complete set of 1996 Dynamic Marketing Signature Gold signature cards with blue certs you standing on a gold mine....

1967Sharks · Feb 26, 2012

Hey Brad $750 is reasonable for that card. Knowing your collection i am assuming you mean high end sigs when you say best.
Here is my list.

2000 Reg Gasnier Legend Signature
2004 Andrew Johns Captains Signature
2002 John Raper Legend Signature
2005 Arthur Beetson Legend Signature
2003 Provan/Summons Legend Duo Signature

Notable Omissions
All of the 2008 Immortals Signatures
2001 Graeme Langlands Legend Signature
2004 Brad Fittler Captains Signature
2009 Darren Lockyer Captains Signature
2003 Darren Lockyer Jersey Signature

tak35bne · Feb 26, 2012

Whilst its not a card the Darren Lockyer signature tazo is prolly one of the hardest to find

1967Sharks · Feb 26, 2012

tak35bne said:
Whilst its not a card the Darren Lockyer signature tazo is prolly one of the hardest to find

You love bringing that up. We need a new thread. Top 5 cards you regret selling

ooneil · Feb 26, 2012

I pretty much agree with Justin's list, however i would drop John's to the bench for the 2001 Langlands Legend Signature.

Tough to leave Locky off but he is just retired and Gasnier, Raper, Beetson, Provan/Summons are certified legends of the game.

1967Sharks · Feb 26, 2012

The thing i dont like about Langlands is his signature. You could have the cleanest design in the world but his sig would just make it look messy.

tak35bne · Feb 26, 2012

1967Sharks said:
You love bringing that up. We need a new thread. Top 5 cards you regret selling

or the top 5 cards you don't regret buying....................

bjs127 · Feb 26, 2012

Some great input there fellas, thanks for taking the time to help out. The Provan/Summons photo is iconic across all Australian sport not just rugby league, hence my interest in the card. Many of you guys on here already got it tucked away in your PCs?

Just wondering has a decent Lewis or Meninga auto been done yet? I assume there is no dual as it would have to be appearing on your lists, but have either got many/any redemption autos? They are two monster names not appearing in any of your lists...

ooneil · Feb 26, 2012

Wally is in the 2008 Centenary signature redemption set and Mal has a signature card in the 2008 Centenary Masters Set.

Both Queenslanders Brad.....bahhhhh

1967Sharks · Feb 26, 2012

Wally Lewis 2008 Immortals Signature
Mal Meninga has had a couple, Neither of them are really good.
This is the rarer one.
http://www.cardzone.com.au/index.cf..._Of_Rugby_League_Master_Set.html?groupid=3725

Yeah maybe monster for a Qlder, They have a gift for overrating their own.

bjs127 · Feb 26, 2012

Ha ha ha quick put the lid back on the can of worms before the Qld v NSW argument comes out!!!

I see there was a Provan/Summons dual also in the 2008 Centenary set but with it being /250 clearly not as rare...although probably a nicer design.

ooneil · Feb 26, 2012

Yeah your right but its a bigger card. Half an A4 page - whatever that is.

I have both and personally prefer the 2003.

mischap123 · Feb 26, 2012

Meninga also has the 1994 gold auto

thenamesgould · Feb 26, 2012

ooneil said:
I pretty much agree with Justin's list, however i would drop John's to the bench for the 2001 Langlands Legend Signature.

Tough to leave Locky off but he is just retired and Gasnier, Raper, Beetson, Provan/Summons are certified legends of the game.

You'd be mad to keep the Johns captain sig off the list ... just because he's not an old-timer doesn't mean he wasn't the best player of all time ... and when it's numbered out of 40, you can't get a more desirable card than that.

rowdy7070 · Feb 26, 2012

andrew johns isn,t a pimple on wallys butt vastly overated .but heaven forbid putting down a newsouth wales player.maybe seeing as how crap you boys have been in origin you can get him to make a comeback ha ha

edabomb · Feb 27, 2012

mischap123 said:
Meninga also has the 1994 gold auto

And the 1994 Kangaroo Heroes auto too. Both numbered too highly to be near this list though.

thenamesgould · Feb 27, 2012

rowdy7070 said:
andrew johns isn,t a pimple on wallys butt vastly overated .but heaven forbid putting down a newsouth wales player.maybe seeing as how crap you boys have been in origin you can get him to make a comeback ha ha

I'm a Kiwi mate, I couldn't care less which state he came from.

Brendan_B · Feb 27, 2012

The card shown on my profile pic would not make the top ten, maybe not even the top 20 but it is still my favourite because Daley is a true legend of the game!

thenamesgould · Feb 28, 2012

That Daley sig is definitely a very nice card indeed - probably the top card for a Canberra supporter.

What are the best 5 NRL cards ever?

Cricket card fanatic

OzCardTrader

OzCardTrader

OzCardTrader

OzCardTrader

OzCardTrader

OzCardTrader

OzCardTrader

Cricket card fanatic

OzCardTrader

OzCardTrader

Cricket card fanatic

OzCardTrader

OzCardTrader

OzCardTrader

OzCardTrader

OzCardTrader

OzCardTrader

OzCardTrader

Similar threads

Privacy & Transparency

Privacy & Transparency