Panini Redemption Replacement Mailday!

Never understood the policy of not having the cards to fulfill these. You happy with the replacements?
Very happy, considering the cards I got are 1000% better than the ones I requested!

My question now is, why weren't the cards I got for redemption replacement actually in the product itself? (They were probably redemptions too)

So now someone else who had the redemptions for the cards I got will have to request a replacement. It's a never ending loop
 
And this is the part that has me scratching my head.
 
Not sure aboutt he NFL - but the Ivey for Anthony is a clear dub - pity it took two years though!