Opinion on this card

ooneil

OzCardTrader

Feedback - 100%

141   0   0

• Aug 17, 2011

• #1

Hey all

1994 Dynamic"RARE" Mal Meninga Autographed Card | eBay

I know this certainly looks okay with the COA letter and redemption card but i wonder if anyone else has seen one signed with a thick black marker??

I have 1 Meninga along with 3 of the Terry Lamb signatures in my collection and they are all signed with a thin blue marker.

Just caught my interest, cheers Owen

 

tak35bne

OzCardTrader

Feedback - 100%

564   0   0

• Aug 17, 2011

• #2

why are you asking us mate, you said it yourself that you are the number 1 authority on cards..................lol, seriously though, I have not ever seen one with a thick marker.............its interesting for sure.

 

bigrob2307

OzCardTrader

Feedback - 100%

134   0   0

• Aug 17, 2011

• #3

haha saw that one earlier. first thought was is the coa the right date? as i know there are a couple diff dates floating round

1st march 1995?

 

thenamesgould

OzCardTrader

Feedback - 100%

10   0   0

• Aug 17, 2011

• #4

Well in later sets those certificates are signed the date they're redeemed (my 1996 Johns signed MVP is like that) but the black marker sig is the big alarm for me. I certainly wouldn't risk $250 on it.

Most like fake.

 

ooneil

OzCardTrader

Feedback - 100%

141   0   0

• Aug 17, 2011

• #5

bigrob2307 said:

haha saw that one earlier. first thought was is the coa the right date? as i know there are a couple diff dates floating round

1st march 1995?

Click to expand...

Didnt you have a Dynamic card with a fake COA Rob.

They dont look to hard to dodgy up.

 

thenamesgould

OzCardTrader

Feedback - 100%

10   0   0

• Aug 17, 2011

• #6

ooneil said:

Didnt you have a Dynamic card with a fake COA Rob.

They dont look to hard to dodgy up.

Click to expand...

The thing that is impossible to totally replicate is the Dynamic letterhead paper. I spose if anyone wants to win that auction we can see if that certificate has proper Dynamic letterhead paper, or if it's come off a desktop printer.

Everything else can be forged, but usually they don't seem to get it 100% right (like with the sig here).

 

bigrob2307

OzCardTrader

Feedback - 100%

134   0   0

• Aug 17, 2011

• #7

yeah i had one i thought was fake in my hand so sent it back to seller and got a refund. never seen him list it again as far as i know

 

mischap123

OzCardTrader

Feedback - 100%

239   0   0

• Aug 17, 2011

• #8

ooneil said:

Hey all

1994 Dynamic"RARE" Mal Meninga Autographed Card | eBay

I know this certainly looks okay with the COA letter and redemption card but i wonder if anyone else has seen one signed with a thick black marker??

I have 1 Meninga along with 3 of the Terry Lamb signatures in my collection and they are all signed with a thin blue marker.

Just caught my interest, cheers Owen

Click to expand...

I never knew they were signed in blue. 1994 S1 is in black but I know they used crappy blue in 1996.
BTW Owen, what will it cost me for one of those Lamb's?

 

bigrob2307

OzCardTrader

Feedback - 100%

134   0   0

• Aug 18, 2011

• #9

and again...

1994 Dynamic"RARE" Terry Lamb Autographed Card | eBay

 

ooneil

OzCardTrader

Feedback - 100%

141   0   0

• Aug 18, 2011

• #10

Yeah see how the marker is different. Maybe im looking to far into things but im very sus on that Meninga.

BTW - that guy is kidding himself at that price.

Still have that Lamb put away for you Bigrob if your interested. Be up your way in a few weeks - will have to catch up.

 

bigrob2307

OzCardTrader

Feedback - 100%

134   0   0

• Aug 18, 2011

• #11

yeah i havent forgotten mate. let me know wat ur chasing again for it. yeah just a lil bit overpriced. BUT i saw a 1994 masters 110 card set go for $100 plus delivery the other day lmao all i could think was u lucky b*stard hahaha. id be a millionare if those prices kept up an we all would be rofl

 

ooneil

OzCardTrader

Feedback - 100%

141   0   0

• Aug 18, 2011

• #12

Yeah you aint wrong there Rob - here it is for everyone else.

http://cgi.ebay.com.au/ws/eBayISAPI....T#ht_500wt_949

Would have to be up there with the worst purchases ever....if anyone wants a set for this price i have a bunch of them sitting in my cupboard

Ohh no - listing removed! It was a 1994 Masters Base set that sold for $99.99................

 

hybridtheory13

OzCardTrader

Feedback - 100%

56   0   0

• Aug 19, 2011

• #13

hey buddy went thru my 1994 folder today when i was sorting stuff out. my terry lamb is signed with a fine point blue pen but my meninga is signed with a thicker black marker...my COAs all match the redemption numbers and the number on the card and i got my card from Tony B so im pretty confident mine is legit