number or sig

[Darrenemu]

Hi all, just saw Dave sell a hindmarsh and i assume he has another one still.
My question is if people have 2 of a premium card and wish to get rid of one (and both in mint cond) do u always keep the smaller number or pick which signature looks best to keep? or is this just a silly question?
Darren

 

[ch0pzta]

I pondered this very question a few weeks ago, would people favour a better sig with a high number or a low numbered card with lower quality signature?

You always see "LOW NUMBER" on sig listings, but never "GREAT QUALITY SIGNATURE"

 

[Wizzle]

If we all graded cards like in the US the quality of the sig would be a big factor

 

[1967Sharks]

I consider 9 or under low. So if i had #38 and #72, I would definitely keep the better sig.

 

[GiRDS-]

unless it was a jersey numbered i wouldn't care

 

[ooneil]

Definitely the better sig. Everytime. Especially when your looking at sigs that have come direct from packets.

Rather have a #290 clean and not scratched sig rather than a #20 scratched sig.

 

[the game rugby league]

Good Question Personally number only if it is number 2

 

[Tanswell87]

When I got rid of my second Lockyer sig the signature was slightly better on the card numberd 20 odd but I was never going to get rid of the 002 for a slightly better sig.

 

[orsum12]

I recently sold a couple of captain signatures Norton and Betham because I brought a nearly complete captains set all the same number I have to say the Norton signature I sold was a nicer looking signature than the 1 I kept, it's just the fact they it's a part of 9 captain cards i have that are all the same number.

 

[1967Sharks]

I recently sold a couple of captain signatures Norton and Betham because I brought a nearly complete captains set all the same number I have to say the Norton signature I sold was a nicer looking signature than the 1 I kept, it's just the fact they it's a part of 9 captain cards i have that are all the same number.

Ohh you have to scan those up. Out of curiousity, what number?

 

[Noark-99]

I recently sold a couple of captain signatures Norton and Betham because I brought a nearly complete captains set all the same number I have to say the Norton signature I sold was a nicer looking signature than the 1 I kept, it's just the fact they it's a part of 9 captain cards i have that are all the same number.

Yes.... Yes.... The Norton was a very good sig!!! and for me.. Being a cowboys collector.... I always go for a better sig!!

What number are all yours?!

M.

 

[Matt26]

Id always go for the better signature, unless its jersey numbered.

 

[hobo]

ditto...........better signature