Hey man,
I have the same sort of problem with a Paul Pierce Finest RC.
I have the standard peeled RC, and the unpeeled RC. I also have a weird one, it's peeled and looks the same as the standard RC, but the back has a refractor-type coating on it and it doesn't have "refractor" printed near the card number? How can you tell the difference from looking at the front if they don't write "refractor" on the back somewhere??
To me the 1st Barkley looks like its missing a black layer, the cyan magenta and yellow have made the black up. That would be my guess, as im a printer i see stuff like that all the time.