Concept is brill but depends what kind of gamers.
They will lose the market of casual gamers who don't want to spend their first 24 hours of playing NBA Elite 11 learning how to shoot.
Some people want to pick the game up and within a few hours get the hang straight away. I don't think you get that with the shooting. Honestly to shoot straight you have to point the stick completely straight. That's VERY hard to do.