It is not a fake, but here is why:
- It is not a card!! It is a folded piece of paper with a piece of material stuck inside it
- The court case allowed them to sell these because the had a disclaimer saying that they are not cards - even though they are CLEARLY trying to give the impression that they are cards when selling
- There is no guarantee that the material is game worn or even of the player on the card. There is also no way to prove otherwise, hence the stalemate
It is what it is, people have them, people buy them. Roger is clearly stating what the 'item' is in the description, even though he sais 'duel' lol
Keep in mind too, the only reason people find these cards funny is because THEY are assuming it is meant to be a card! If you just think of it as a piece of material, then not so much!
As he said, it is up to the buyer, but personally, I would NEVER support any company who is blatantly trying to mislead people toi buy their products! This goes for everything, not just memorabilia! I saw a bag of chips at the shops that was 175g but they make the packet the same physical size as the ones that are still 200g, just so you think theirs are cheaper!
Scammers are everywhere, NSA are no different to the other 50 companies that I can think of that try anything to mislead their customers!