Elite League Sensations Autos 2013 vs 2014....which player do you choose?

[Matt26]

Ok everyone, here is a fun little game while we are waiting for 2014 Elite to come out........from the list of ESP Elite League Sensations for both 2013 and 2014, create your ideal checklist of cards from both sets.

As an example, for Melbourne you can only choose one card Billy Slater 2013 or Cameron Smith 2014.

2013
Brisbane Broncos - Scott Prince
Canberra Raiders - David Shillington
Canterbury Bulldogs - Ben Barba
Cronulla Sharks - Paul Gallen
Gold Coast Titans - Nate Myles
Manly Sea Eagles - Keiran Foran
Melbourne Storm - Billy Slater
Newcastle Knights - Danny Buderus
Nth Queensland Cowboys - Jonathan Thurston
Parramatta Eels - Jarryd Hayne
Penrith Panthers - Tim Grant
South Sydney Rabbitohs - Greg Inglis
St George Dragons - Brett Morris
Sydney Roosters - Mitchell Pearce
Auckland Warriors - Shaun Johnson
Wests Tigers - Benji Marshall


2014
Brisbane Broncos - Corey Parker
Canberra Raiders - Terry Campese
Canterbury Bulldogs - Michael Ennis
Cronulla Sharks - Michael Gordon
Gold Coast Titans - Greg Bird
Manly Sea Eagles - Brett Stewart
Melbourne Storm - Cameron Smith
Newcastle Knights - Darius Boyd
Nth Queensland Cowboys - Matt Scott
Parramatta Eels - Tim Mannah
Penrith Panthers - David Simmons
South Sydney Rabbitohs - John Sutton
St George Dragons - Trent Merrin
Sydney Roosters - Anthony Minichiello
Auckland Warriors - Simon Mannering
Wests Tigers - Liam Fulton

My List is:

Brisbane Broncos - Corey Parker (2014)
Canberra Raiders - Terry Campese (2014)
Canterbury Bulldogs - Ben Barba (2013)
Cronulla Sharks - Paul Gallen (2013)
Gold Coast Titans - Greg Bird (2014)
Manly Sea Eagles - Brett Stewart (2014)
Melbourne Storm - Cameron Smith (2014)
Newcastle Knights - Danny Buderus (2013)
Nth Queensland Cowboys - Jonathan Thurston (2013)
Parramatta Eels - Jarryd Hayne (2013)
Penrith Panthers - Tim Grant (2013)
South Sydney Rabbitohs - Greg Inglis (2013)
St George Dragons - Brett Morris (2013)
Sydney Roosters - Anthony Minichiello (2014)
Auckland Warriors - Shaun Johnson (2013)
Wests Tigers - Benji Marshall (2013)

What is your list?

Cheers
Matt

 

[joeyhonson]

Brisbane Broncos - Corey Parker (2014)
Canberra Raiders - Terry Campese (2014)
Canterbury Bulldogs - Ben Barba (2013)
Cronulla Sharks - Paul Gallen (2013)
Gold Coast Titans - Greg Bird (2014)
Manly Sea Eagles - Brett Stewart (2014)
Melbourne Storm - Billy Slater (2013) - very hard to pick
Newcastle Knights - Danny Buderus (2013)
Nth Queensland Cowboys - Jonathan Thurston (2013)
Parramatta Eels - Jarryd Hayne (2013)
Penrith Panthers - David Simmons (2014) - very hard to pick for the opposite reason
South Sydney Rabbitohs - Greg Inglis (2013)
St George Dragons - Brett Morris (2013)
Sydney Roosters - Anthony Minichiello (2014)
Auckland Warriors - Shaun Johnson (2013)
Wests Tigers - Benji Marshall (2013)

 

[Tap Twist Snap]

Brisbane Broncos - Scott Prince
Canberra Raiders - David Shillington
Canterbury Bulldogs - Michael Ennis
Cronulla Sharks - Paul Gallen
Gold Coast Titans - Greg Bird
Manly Sea Eagles - Brett Stewart
Melbourne Storm - Cameron Smith
Newcastle Knights - Danny Buderus
Nth Queensland Cowboys - Jonathan Thurston
Parramatta Eels - Jarryd Hayne
Penrith Panthers - Tim Grant
South Sydney Rabbitohs - Greg Inglis
St George Dragons - Brett Morris
Sydney Roosters - Anthony Minichiello
Auckland Warriors - Shaun Johnson
Wests Tigers - Benji Marshall

 

[nznrl]

Was thinking about doing this myself

Brisbane Broncos - Corey Parker (2014)
Canberra Raiders - David Shillington (2013), want neither really...
Canterbury Bulldogs - Ben Barba (2013)
Cronulla Sharks - Paul Gallen (2013)
Gold Coast Titans - Greg Bird (2014)
Manly Sea Eagles - Kieran Foran (2013)
Melbourne Storm - Billy Slater (2013)
Newcastle Knights - Danny Buderus (2013)
Nth Queensland Cowboys - Jonathan Thurston (2013)
Parramatta Eels - Jarryd Hayne (2013)
Penrith Panthers - Tim Grant (2013)
South Sydney Rabbitohs - Greg Inglis (2013)
St George Dragons - Brett Morris (2013)
Sydney Roosters - Anthony Minichiello (2014)
Auckland Warriors - Shaun Johnson (2013)
Wests Tigers - Benji Marshall (2013)

13 from 2013, 3 from 2014 for me. Makes me worried about the re-sale value: a lot of cards at the Shillington/Myles value range from last year

However, the Young Guns are far more appetising than the Future Stars

 

[Matt26]

Was thinking about doing this myself

13 from 2013, 3 from 2014 for me. Makes me worried about the re-sale value: a lot of cards at the Shillington/Myles value range from last year

However, the Young Guns are far more appetising than the Future Stars

I had 6 from 2014 and 10 from 2013.

Cant wait for the Young Guns this year!

 

[Dragon_Fire]

Brisbane Broncos - Corey Parker 2014
Canberra Raiders - Terry Campese 2014
Canterbury Bulldogs - Ben Barba 2013
Cronulla Sharks - Paul Gallen 2014
Gold Coast Titans - Greg Bird 2014
Manly Sea Eagles - Brett Stewart 2014
Melbourne Storm - Cameron Smith 2014
Newcastle Knights - Danny Buderus 2013
Nth Queensland Cowboys - Jonathan Thurston 2013
Parramatta Eels - Jarryd Hayne 2014
Penrith Panthers - Tim Grant 2013
South Sydney Rabbitohs - Greg Inglis 2013
St George Dragons - Brett Morris 2013
Sydney Roosters - Anthony Minichiello 2014
Auckland Warriors - Shaun Johnson 2013
Wests Tigers - Benji Marshall 2013

2013-8 2014 8

 

[hobo]

For me:

Brisbane Broncos - Corey Parker (2014)
Canberra Raiders - Terry Campese (2014)
Canterbury Bulldogs - Michael Ennis (2014)
Cronulla Sharks - Paul Gallen (2013)
Gold Coast Titans - Greg Bird (2014)
Manly Sea Eagles - Brett Stewart (2014)
Melbourne Storm - Cameron Smith (2014)
Newcastle Knights - Danny Buderus (2013)
Nth Queensland Cowboys - Jonathan Thurston (2013)
Parramatta Eels - Jarryd Hayne (2013)
Penrith Panthers - Tim Grant (2013)
South Sydney Rabbitohs - Greg Inglis (2013)
St George Dragons -Trent Merrin (2014)
Sydney Roosters - Anthony Minichiello (2014)
NZ Warriors - Shaun Johnson (2013)
Wests Tigers - Benji Marshall (2013)

8 for 2014 and 8 for 2013

I'm in the minority with Merrin though.

Ross

 

[Colesy]

Brisbane Broncos - Corey Parker (2014)
Canberra Raiders - Terry Campese (2014)
Canterbury Bulldogs - Ben Barba (2013)
Cronulla Sharks - Paul Gallen (2013)
Gold Coast Titans - Greg Bird (2014)
Manly Sea Eagles - Brett Stewart (2014)
Melbourne Storm - Cameron Smith (2014) - Only just
Newcastle Knights - Danny Buderus (2013)
Nth Queensland Cowboys - Jonathan Thurston (2013)
Parramatta Eels - Jarryd Hayne (2013)
Penrith Panthers - Tim Grant (2013)
South Sydney Rabbitohs - Greg Inglis (2013)
St George Dragons - Brett Morris (2013)
Sydney Roosters - Anthony Minichiello (2014)
Auckland Warriors - Shaun Johnson (2013)
Wests Tigers - Benji Marshall (2013)


10 from 2013 & 6 from 2014

 

[hobo]

It's a tough question and looking again there is a couple I could have gone either way on .

Morris over Merrin seems popular.
Sutton is a great choice and Inglis well he's a Queenslander.
Foran over Stewart wouldn't be a bad decision.
Slater's good but overdone so Smith it is but again either is good.
Mannering is the heart and sole of NZ, Johnson a gun

So there's 2 x 2013 and 2 x 2014 I could swap, but combined it is an impressive lot of sigs in 2 years and ESP should be congratulated IMO.

Cheers
Ross

 

[Kreepz]

Brisbane Broncos - Corey Parker
Canberra Raiders - Terry Campese
Canterbury Bulldogs - Ben Barba
Cronulla Sharks - Paul Gallen
Gold Coast Titans - Greg Bird
Manly Sea Eagles - Brett Stewart
Melbourne Storm - Cameron Smith
Newcastle Knights - Danny Buderus
Nth Queensland Cowboys - Jonathan Thurston
Parramatta Eels - Jarryd Hayne
Penrith Panthers - Tim Grant
South Sydney Rabbitohs - Greg Inglis
St George Dragons - Brett Morris
Sydney Roosters - Anthony Minichiello
Auckland Warriors - Shaun Johnson
Wests Tigers - Benji Marshall

 

[Diggaz TC]

Brisbane Broncos - Corey Parker
Canberra Raiders - Terry Campese
Canterbury Bulldogs - Ben Barba
Cronulla Sharks - Paul Gallen
Gold Coast Titans - Greg Bird
Manly Sea Eagles - Brett Stewart
Melbourne Storm - Cameron Smith (Mainly due to having our fair share of Slater Sigs over the years)
Newcastle Knights - Danny Buderus
Nth Queensland Cowboys - Jonathan Thurston
Parramatta Eels - Jarryd Hayne
Penrith Panthers - Tim Grant
South Sydney Rabbitohs - Greg Inglis
St George Dragons - Brett Morris
Sydney Roosters - Anthony Minichiello
Auckland Warriors - Shaun Johnson
Wests Tigers - Benji Marshall

 

[Jaede]

Brisbane Broncos - Corey Parker (2014)
Canberra Raiders - Terry Campese (2014)
Canterbury Bulldogs - Ben Barba (2013)
Cronulla Sharks - Paul Gallen (2013)
Gold Coast Titans - Greg Bird (2014)
Manly Sea Eagles - Brett Stewart (2014)
Melbourne Storm - Cameron Smith (2014)
Newcastle Knights - Danny Buderus (2013)
Nth Queensland Cowboys - Jonathan Thurston (2013)
Parramatta Eels - Jarryd Hayne (2013) (hard to pick love that Mannah now has a signature card but hard to go past Hayne)
Penrith Panthers - Tim Grant (2013)
South Sydney Rabbitohs - Greg Inglis (2013)
St George Dragons - Brett Morris (2013)
Sydney Roosters - Anthony Minichiello (2014)
Auckland Warriors - Simon Mannering (2014)
Wests Tigers - Benji Marshall (2013)