My Stuart card starts the same way, just a little higher & ends in the far corner. I pulled mine from a pack when they were released. Will try put a pic up
I worked in a card shop back when these were around. The one at the top looks legit to me. I remember seeing Walters that were similar. The top side of the embossing had signature on but the gold had been stamped over it so covered the rest of the signature.
Thats it why have it signed if you cannot see the sig. The other thing I hate is when the sig is in thick nicko over the players face could be anyones pic.