Poor condition predictors/ redemptions

meeda13 · Friday at 4:48 PM

Niche question - but how much would a poor condition predictor/ redemption affect the value of a card? I will redeem it soon so signature card will be in good condition, I'm hoping. Picture for example.

ElijahCraigHyde · Friday at 6:13 PM

meeda13 said:
Niche question - but how much would a poor condition predictor/ redemption affect the value of a card? I will redeem it soon so signature card will be in good condition, I'm hoping. Picture for example.

IMO the dodgy corners don't matter because the card is a redemption card. I believe I know this because I have had booklet cards requiring redemption and have lost the redemption cards all together! Some may say a missing redemption card might devalue the card via such redemption but as long as the redemption destination is tack then that's what counts

absti3 · Friday at 9:32 PM

I wouldn’t buy one on secondary market without a redemption or with the redemption in less than mint (my idea of mint condition) but that’s me. For some,it’s not an issue for them.

meeda13 · Friday at 9:56 PM

absti3 said:
I wouldn’t buy one on secondary market without a redemption or with the redemption in less than mint (my idea of mint condition) but that’s me. For some,it’s not an issue for them.

Same. But I got this one really cheap so I’m going to have to accept it’s less than ideal

BLOWN8 · Saturday at 7:21 AM

absti3 said:
I wouldn’t buy one on secondary market without a redemption or with the redemption in less than mint (my idea of mint condition) but that’s me. For some,it’s not an issue for them.

I have to agree, redemption card is part of the card set, nothing but mint condition for me. Also, I would never buy a signature card if it was via redemption but the redemption card was missing.
But that’s just me. If you got it at a good price and are happy then that’s what matters. The booklet will be mint so you can display that nicely.
But to answer your question, it will absolutely effect the price being in that condition.

meeda13 · Saturday at 8:39 AM

BLOWN8 said:
I have to agree, redemption card is part of the card set, nothing but mint condition for me. Also, I would never buy a signature card if it was via redemption but the redemption card was missing.
But that’s just me. If you got it at a good price and are happy then that’s what matters. The booklet will be mint so you can display that nicely.
But to answer your question, it will absolutely effect the price being in that condition.

Yeah thought so. Thanks

Poor condition predictors/ redemptions

meeda13

OzCardTrader

ElijahCraigHyde

OzCardTrader

absti3

OzCardTrader

meeda13

OzCardTrader

BLOWN8

Such is life!

meeda13

OzCardTrader

Similar threads